2026年10月下旬,湛江科技学院副教授冯志红在《中国教育报》发表文章指出,因学生评教结果纳入考核压力,部分教师出现“讨好式教学”现象 1。通过与上海交通大学邢磊及江苏师范大学周继良等专家对话,报道揭示了该现象的三种主要表现:给分交换型、直接示好型和指标顺应型 1。具体而言,给分交换型表现为降低难度或减少作业;直接示好型包括送礼物或暗示好评;指标顺应型则体现为回避认知困难 1。
实证研究表明,放宽给分、降低难度、减少作业与学生满意度之间的相关性并不强 1。尽管如此,评教压力仍导致教师偏离教学目标以换取好评 1。邢磊接触的一位年轻老师为避免负面评价,在临近评教的前几周不布置作业 1。此外,冯志红的一位好友教授工程制图实训课,因连续3个学期评教成绩倒数,整改后删减专业训练内容,虽然评教分数提高,但已偏离教学目标 1。
In late October 2026, Associate Professor Feng Zhihong from Zhanjiang College of Science and Technology published an article in the China Education Daily highlighting a concerning trend in higher education: teachers engaging in "pleasing pedagogy" to secure better student evaluation scores. 1 Feng cited the case of a friend who teaches engineering drawing practice; after receiving bottom-tier evaluation results for three consecutive semesters, the instructor removed specialized training content during rectification efforts. 1 Although this adjustment improved evaluation scores, it ultimately caused the course to deviate from its original educational objectives. 1
To address this phenomenon, Southern Weekly News organized a dialogue featuring experts including Xing Lei from Shanghai Jiao Tong University and Zhou Jiliang from Jiangsu Normal University. 1 Xing Lei categorized "pleasing pedagogy" into three primary manifestations: grade exchange, where instructors lower difficulty levels or reduce homework assignments; direct flattery, involving gifts or hints requesting positive reviews; and metric compliance, which entails avoiding cognitively challenging material. 1 He noted that one young teacher under his observation stopped assigning homework in the weeks leading up to evaluation periods specifically to avoid negative feedback. 1
Despite these strategic adjustments by educators, empirical research indicates a weak correlation between relaxing grading standards, lowering course difficulty, or reducing workload and actual increases in student satisfaction. 1 Nevertheless, the pressure exerted by the integration of student evaluations into faculty assessment systems continues to drive some teachers away from core teaching goals in pursuit of favorable ratings. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。