中南大学于11月19日发布情况通报,认定其附属湘雅二医院及湘雅医院涉及的3篇论文存在伪造篡改实验研究数据和图表、不当署名及违反科研伦理规范等学术不端行为 12。事件源于网络质疑,网友指出论文细节异常,包括作者单位“湖南省”误写为“人类省”,以及标尺图片中1厘米范围内竟有12个刻度格,疑似由AI生成 12。校方据此对相关责任人进行了严肃处理 12。
此次处理涉及邓某某、赵某、蔡某、谭某某4人,具体处罚措施根据责任程度有所区别 12。对于第一作者邓某某和通讯作者赵某(涉及《Journal of Translational Medicine》论文),学校给予降低专业技术岗位等级处罚,5年内取消职务职称晋升资格,10年内不得承担财政性资金支持科技活动 12。对于涉及《Cell Death & Disease》论文的蔡某(第一作者)、谭某某(共同第一作者)及赵某(通讯作者),以及涉及《Scientific Reports》论文(校外人员一作/共一,邓某某通讯)的相关责任,对蔡某、谭某某给予5年内取消职务职称晋升资格、5年内不得承担财政性资金支持科技活动的处罚 12。通报明确指出,这3篇被质疑的期刊论文均存在伪造篡改数据图表的问题,其中两篇还伴有不当署名 2。
Central South University released a formal notification on November 19 confirming academic misconduct in three research papers associated with its affiliated hospitals, the Second Xiangya Hospital and Xiangya Hospital 12. The investigation determined that these publications involved fabricating or tampering with experimental data and charts, improper authorship attribution, and violations of research ethics standards 12. As a result, four individuals—Deng, Zhao, Cai, and Tan—received disciplinary measures ranging from professional title demotions to long-term bans on leading government-funded scientific projects 12.
The scrutiny originated from online critics who identified anomalies within the published images, including the mislabeling of "Hunan Province" as "Humanity Province" and suspicious visuals, such as a one-centimeter ruler containing twelve distinct markings which raised suspicion of AI generation 12. Specific journals affected by these findings were Journal of Translational Medicine, Cell Death & Disease, and Scientific Reports 12. In the first paper, Deng served as the first author and Zhao as the corresponding author; the second featured Cai as first author, Tan as co-first author, and Zhao as corresponding author; while the third had external personnel as authors with Deng acting as the corresponding author 2. All three studies contained evidence of manipulated data and graphical fraud 2.
Punishments were differentiated based on the severity and role of each individual. Deng and Zhao were demoted in their professional technical positions, barred from promotions for five years, and prohibited from undertaking fiscally supported scientific activities for ten years 12. Cai and Tan received penalties that included a five-year ban on promotion-related qualifications and a prohibition on leading fiscally supported scientific activities for the same duration 12.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。