11月10日,湖北枫叶律师事务所执业律师黄琴在律所办公室因持续高压劳累倒地,经抢救无效于两日后去世,年仅48岁1。由于黄琴以灵活就业人员身份参保,其社保未包含工伤保险项目,武汉市人社局工作人员确认此类参保方式不在工伤保障范围内1。律所主任高杰称双方仅为劳务关系,因此无法享受工亡待遇1。当地律协表示可为病故律师支付3万元至5万元的保险赔偿金1。
这一事件引发了关于“提成律师”与律所是否存在劳动关系及能否纳入工伤保险的社会讨论1。若不考虑抚恤金,按《工伤保险条例》标准计算,基于2025年数据预估的一次性工亡补助金等合计约为118万元1。中央财经大学法学院教授沈建峰指出,只有存在劳动关系时才能纳入工伤保险;判断关键在于双方关系的实质而非名义,需考察是否接受考勤、奖惩及收入发放形式等管理关系1。司法实践中,近期法院多倾向于认定无劳动关系,除非有明确的管理从属证据1。但部分劳动法专家观点认为,若律师通过律所参加了职工社会保险,行政机关应认可其资格,不能事后以无劳动关系为由拒绝工伤保障1。
Huang Qin, a 48-year-old practicing lawyer at Hubei Fengye Law Firm in Wuhan, collapsed in her office due to sustained high-pressure fatigue and died two days later after resuscitation efforts failed 1. This tragedy has brought the issue of labor rights protection for “commission-based lawyers,” a common model in the legal industry, into sharp focus. The central dispute concerns whether such practitioners have an employment relationship or a service relationship with their firms, which determines their eligibility for workers’ compensation benefits 1.
According to Gao Jie, the director of the law firm, Huang had enrolled in social insurance as a flexible-employment individual, a category that does not include work-related injury insurance. The firm characterized its relationship with Huang as a service contract rather than an employment relationship, thereby precluding her family from receiving death-benefit compensation under work-injury regulations 1. The local bar association stated it could provide an insurance compensation payment ranging from 30,000 to 50,000 yuan for lawyers who die from illness 1. In contrast, if calculated according to the Regulations on Work-Related Injury Insurance—excluding funeral subsidies—the lump-sum death grant and other related costs would amount to approximately 1.18 million yuan based on projected 2025 data, highlighting a significant disparity 1. A staff member from the Wuhan Human Resources and Social Security Bureau confirmed that flexible-employment insurance currently excludes work-related injury coverage. They noted that if an employer has paid standard employee social security contributions, recognition of the employment relationship via a labor contract or arbitration is required to proceed with a work-injury claim 1.
Regarding the legal classification of such cases, Shen Jianfeng, a professor at the Central University of Finance and Economics, pointed out that the determination hinges on the substance of the relationship rather than its nominal label. Key factors include whether the lawyer is subject to the firm’s attendance and reward/punishment management systems and the nature of income distribution 1. Although judicial practice regarding the status of commission-based lawyers remains inconsistent, recent court rulings have tended to deny the existence of an employment relationship unless there is clear evidence of managerial subordination 1. Conversely, some labor law experts argue that if a lawyer has participated in employee social insurance through the law firm, administrative authorities should recognize their eligibility and not subsequently refuse work-injury protection on the grounds that no employment relationship exists 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。