尽管人类解剖学研究已历经两千五百余年,但关于“新器官”的认定仍存在显著分歧 1。两位解剖学家 Amanda Meyer 和 Jamie Chapman 指出,当前人体解剖学领域的争议主要源于正常的人体变异、获取新鲜组织的高成本与繁琐程序、化学固定剂对结构外观的改变,以及尸体捐献者多为老年人所导致的病理偏差 1。在此背景下,三个涉及头部的具体案例凸显了学界对于新发现的审慎态度 1。
首先,大脑清除废物的机制尚未达成共识 1。传统观点认为废物通过蛛网膜颗粒排出,而新兴理论则提出类淋巴系统(glymphatic system)在其中的作用 1。该系统可能与阿尔茨海默病中淀粉样蛋白β的积累有关,但其存在性仍具争议 1。
其次,关于人类犁鼻器(又称雅各布森氏器)的功能争论持续存在 1。虽然在动物体内该器官用于探测信息素,但在人类中因缺乏感觉神经元和神经连接,它广泛被认为只是失去主要功能的进化残留物 1。
最后,2021年通过成像技术识别出的咽鼓管腺(tubarial glands)引发了最新一轮辩论 1。这一长约4厘米的结构被提议为第四对主要唾液腺,但批评者反驳称,其本质是散布在口腔、舌头和喉咙内衬中的小唾液腺或附属唾液腺 1。主要唾液腺负责分泌消化酶,而小唾液腺仅贡献润滑和湿润粘液 1。尽管咽鼓管腺是否会被正式写入教科书尚待定论,但在制定头颈部癌症放射治疗计划时,必须考虑到对该结构造成损伤的风险 1。
Despite more than 2,500 years of human anatomical study, significant debates persist regarding what constitutes a truly new organ discovery 1. Two experts have analyzed three prominent cases related to head and neck anatomy that have sparked controversy, ranging from brain waste clearance mechanisms to proposed salivary glands 1. These disputes highlight the complexities of modern anatomical research, where findings often depend on varying interpretations of structural functions and definitions 1.
One major area of contention involves how the brain removes metabolic waste. Traditional understanding points to arachnoid granulations, while newer hypotheses suggest a glymphatic system may be responsible; however, the existence of this pathway remains disputed among researchers 1. The proposed glymphatic system has been linked to the accumulation of amyloid beta in Alzheimer’s disease 1. Another long-standing debate concerns the vomeronasal organ, also known as Jacobson’s organ, which aids in pheromone detection in many animals but is widely considered an evolutionary vestige in humans due to the lack of associated sensory neurons and neural connections 1.
Most recently, a structure termed the tubarial gland was identified via imaging technology in 2021 and proposed as the fourth pair of major salivary glands, measuring approximately 4 centimeters in length 1. Critics argue that these structures are not novel organs but rather existing minor or accessory salivary glands scattered throughout the lining of the mouth, tongue, and throat 1. While major salivary glands contribute digestive enzymes, minor ones primarily provide lubricating mucus, leading to skepticism about whether the tubarial glands will be reclassified in textbooks soon 1. Nevertheless, recognizing their location is clinically relevant for planning radiotherapy treatments for head and neck cancers to avoid unnecessary damage 1.
Such anatomical controversies arise from inherent variations in human bodies, alongside methodological challenges including the high cost and bureaucratic hurdles of obtaining fresh tissue samples 1. Additionally, the appearance of structures can be altered by chemical fixatives, and reliance on cadaver donors, who are predominantly elderly, introduces biases related to age-associated pathological changes 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。