当前,部分电商平台及二手平台上的“免押租赁”服务存在以风险控制为名,向消费者过度索取个人隐私信息的问题 1。商家在租赁过程中往往要求用户提供身份证、手机号、家庭住址等基础信息之外,还强制索要通讯录、微信好友列表、微信流水记录乃至工作群聊录屏等敏感数据,理由均为“风控需要” 1。此类行为不仅侵犯了消费者隐私,更衍生出违规催收与信息曝光乱象,例如逾期后催收电话骚扰父母及同事,或因用户给出差评而实名公开其个人信息 1。
针对这一现象,法律专家岳屾山指出,信息收集必须严格遵循“最小必要原则”,目前广泛存在的对通讯录、金融账户信息等数据的采集属于过度收集,涉嫌违法 1。另一位法律专家赵占领建议,行业应优先利用征信体系或平台履约数据来核验用户信誉,明确禁止采集非必要敏感信息,并建立交易终止后的信息清理与删除机制 1。
在具体案例中,消费者赵女士遭遇商家层层加码,被要求提供机票、住宿截图、工作证明、社保记录以及微信工作群录屏等大量隐私材料 1。此外,还有商家利用支付宝免押自动扣款机制,仅因镜头盖丢失便扣除高达833元的费用,远超物品实际价值 1。对此,专家提醒消费者在授权代扣协议时需格外谨慎,以防陷入超额扣款的风险陷阱 1。
Deposit-free rental services on e-commerce and second-hand platforms have sparked controversy due to the excessive collection of consumer personal information under the pretext of risk control. Merchants require users to provide not only basic details such as ID cards, mobile phone numbers, and home addresses, but also sensitive data including contact lists, WeChat friend lists, WeChat transaction records, and even screen recordings of work group chats 1. In one case, a consumer named Ms. Zhao was asked to submit screenshots of flight tickets and accommodation bookings, proof of employment, social security records, and screen recordings of her WeChat work groups when applying for the service 1. These practices have been criticized for severely infringing on user privacy. Furthermore, issues such as illegal debt collection and information exposure have arisen during overdue payments or disputes, with examples including harassing calls made to consumers’ parents and colleagues, or the public revelation of personal information in retaliation for negative reviews 1.
Legal experts state that this method of information collection is suspected of being illegal. China News cites legal expert Yue Shen Shan, who points out that information collection must strictly follow the "minimum necessary principle." He notes that collecting data such as contact lists and financial account information constitutes excessive collection, which not only violates personal privacy but also disturbs the peace of third parties 1. Another legal expert, Zhao Zhanying, suggests that platforms should prioritize using credit reporting systems or their own performance data to verify user credibility, prohibit the collection of unnecessary sensitive information, and establish mechanisms for cleaning and deleting data after transactions are terminated 1. Risks extend beyond privacy leaks to financial safety; in one instance, a merchant deducted 833 yuan via Alipay’s automatic deposit-free payment mechanism solely on the grounds of a lost lens cap, an amount far exceeding the item's actual value 1. Experts advise consumers to be cautious when authorizing automatic deduction agreements to prevent the risk of excessive charges 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。