河南广播电视台《小莉帮忙》栏目近日展开实地测试,发现家庭维修行业仍存在“小病大修”现象。在针对电池没电、气阀关闭等简单故障的咨询中,来自啄木鸟、天鹅到家及58到家的5名维修师傅里,仅有2人如实告知情况,其余3人均虚报复杂问题并收取超过百元的费用 1。这一乱象并非首次被曝光,早在2025年“3·15”晚会期间,啄木鸟家庭维修因乱收费问题被点名,当时该平台曾致歉并承诺“放弃公关”,但近期测试显示相关违规行为仍在发生 1。
深入调查揭示了违规操作背后的利益驱动机制。据啄木鸟前网点负责人透露,该公司对订单设有严格考核标准,低于70元的订单被视为“失败单”,且公司从交易中抽取60%的佣金 1。招股书数据显示,2021年至2024年上半年,啄木鸟平台服务收入约占已完成订单总交易额的约40%,而同期三年半内获取流量的开支合计约7.81亿元 1。中新网评论指出,尽管此前有过整改承诺,但由于未触及高抽成比例和以客单价为核心的考核体系等底层规则,导致舆情过后套路反复上演 1。治理此类乱象的关键在于从惩戒个人转向纠偏平台的利益结构,监管部门需进一步压实平台主体责任 1。
A joint media investigation has uncovered widespread fraudulent practices among home repair technicians working for major Chinese platforms. In a field test conducted in Henan Province and other regions, five technicians from services including Woodpecker Home Repair, Swan to Home (Tian'e Daojia), and 58 Daojia were observed 1. The results showed that three of these five technicians falsely reported complex issues when faced with simple problems, such as dead batteries or closed gas valves, subsequently charging customers over 100 yuan 1. Only two of the tested technicians honestly informed customers about the minor nature of the faults 1. This report was published on November 17, 2025, by China News, highlighting findings initially exposed by Henan Broadcasting Television's "Xiao Li Bangmang" program 1.
The recurrence of such misconduct persists despite significant public scrutiny following its exposure during the 2025 "3·15 Gala," where Woodpecker Home Repair was criticized for excessive charges. At that time, the platform apologized and promised to abandon public relations tactics in favor of genuine reform 1. However, an analysis of the industry's underlying incentive structures suggests why these promises have not translated into lasting change. A former regional manager for Woodpecker revealed that orders valued below 70 yuan are classified as failures, while the company retains a 60% commission on transactions 1. According to the platform's prospectus, service income accounted for approximately 40% of the total transaction value of completed orders between 2021 and the first half of 2024, with traffic acquisition costs totaling around 781 million yuan over three and a half years 1.
Critics argue that previous rectifications failed because they did not address the core profit mechanisms driving technician behavior. The reliance on high commissions and performance metrics centered on average customer spending continues to incentivize "repairing small ailments as major breakdowns" 1. Consequently, once public opinion fades, similar deceptive practices tend to resurface 1. The commentary concludes that effective governance must shift from merely punishing individual technicians to correcting the fundamental interest structures of the platforms themselves 1. It further urges regulatory bodies to enforce stricter accountability on platform operators regarding their internal policies 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。