近期,MCN机构与网络创作者之间的签约纠纷频发,主要体现为合同名目繁多、权责不清,导致高额违约金索赔及账号归属争议不断 1。上海大学社会学院副教授项军团队对600多份终审判决的分析显示,签了合同的博主拿到实质赔付的比例不足三成 1。在MCN与博主签订的文书中,合作协议约占一半,经纪协议占三成,而劳动合同占比极低,这导致多数协议非劳动合同,使得博主保障不足 1。
面对这一现状,司法实践正逐步透过合同表象审查实质用工关系,以厘清双方权利义务 1。杭州中院今年9月审结一起案件,二审维持原判,认定王岚、王星与公司存在劳动关系而非合作关系,无需支付分别高达800万元和200万元的违约金 1。法院指出,判断劳动关系的核心标准是人格、经济、组织三重从属性 1。类似地,2025年吉林市船营区人民法院审理的一起案件中,将原索赔5万元的违约金最终认定为1000元 1。
在制度建设方面,《直播电商监督管理办法》已于今年2月1日起施行 1。与此同时,人力资源和社会保障等多部门正在推动《新就业形态劳动者权益保障办法(征求意见稿)》,旨在进一步完善行业规则并建立针对新就业形态劳动者的权益保障机制 1。
MCN agencies are facing intensified scrutiny over widespread contractual irregularities, including ambiguous rights and responsibilities, excessive penalty claims, and disputes over account ownership 1. Research conducted by Professor Xiang Jun’s team at the School of Sociology, Shanghai University, analyzing more than 600 final court judgments, revealed that fewer than 30% of contracted influencers successfully obtained substantive compensation 1. The study further indicated a significant imbalance in contract types, with cooperation agreements accounting for roughly half, management contracts comprising about 30%, and labor contracts representing an extremely small fraction 1. This disparity has left many creators without adequate legal protections typically afforded to employees 1.
In response to these systemic issues, judicial authorities are increasingly piercing through the formal labels of contracts to assess the substance of employment relationships 1. In a notable case concluded by the Hangzhou Intermediate People's Court in September of this year, the second-instance ruling upheld the finding that Wang Lan and Wang Xing had established labor relationships rather than cooperative partnerships with their agency, thereby exempting them from paying massive breach-of-contract fees totaling 8 million yuan and 2 million yuan respectively 1. Courts determine such labor relationships based on the core criteria of personal, economic, and organizational subordination 1. Similarly, in a 2025 case heard by the Chuanying District People's Court in Jilin City, the initially claimed penalty of 50,000 yuan was significantly reduced to just 1,000 yuan upon review 1.
Regulatory efforts are also accelerating to standardize industry practices and protect workers' rights 1. The "Measures for the Supervision and Administration of Live-streaming E-commerce" officially came into effect on February 1 of this year 1. Meanwhile, multiple government departments, led by the Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security, are actively promoting the formulation of the "Measures for the Protection of Rights and Interests of Workers in New Forms of Employment (Draft for Public Comment)" to establish clearer rules for this evolving sector 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。