北京大兴区西红门嘉悦广场多名业主反映,开发商在购房合同中约定代收写字楼专项维修资金,业主认为该行为不合法。1 2016年,王女士购买该处写字楼时,按每平方米200元的标准向开发商缴纳了专项维修资金。1
大兴区住房城乡建设物业科表示,目前无文件规定纯商业楼需收专项维修资金,嘉悦广场的情况属开发商与业主的合同行为。1 北京市住建委2021年印发的《关于禁止房地产开发企业违规收取契税和住宅专项维修资金有关问题的通知》,仅针对“住宅”,未涵盖此类非住宅项目。1
首都经济贸易大学赵秀池教授指出,国家层面无强制法定缴纳义务,若无地方规章,设立维修资金属民事约定;同时提醒开发商代收有资金挪用风险。1 律师翟羽佳提到,北京部分法院判决认定“委托开发商代收”条款对双方有约束力,但在开发商长期未代缴、资金去向不明时,法院可能支持业主返还诉求。1
2026年10月,北京12345热线反馈称,大兴区住建委已约谈开发商北京盛玺置业有限公司。1 由于行政部门无强制退款权限,官方建议通过司法途径解决争议。1
Owners at the Jia Yue Plaza office building in Xihongmen, Daxing District, Beijing, are challenging the legality of their developer collecting special maintenance funds through purchase contracts. In 2016, Ms. Wang paid 200 yuan per square meter to the developer as a special maintenance fund upon purchasing her unit 1. The dispute centers on whether this practice complies with current regulations, given that recent municipal guidelines explicitly prohibiting such collections by developers apply only to residential properties 1.
Legal and administrative authorities indicate that there is no mandatory statutory basis for collecting special maintenance funds from pure commercial office buildings. A 2021 notice issued by the Beijing Municipal Commission of Housing and Urban-Rural Development bans real estate companies from illegally collecting deed taxes and housing-specific maintenance funds, but its scope is limited to "residential" units 1. Consequently, the Property Management Section of the Daxing District Housing and Urban-Rural Development Bureau stated that the situation at Jia Yue Plaza constitutes a contractual agreement between the developer and owners, as no regulation requires the collection of such funds for purely commercial buildings 1.
Experts warn that without local rules mandating these payments, establishing maintenance funds remains a matter of civil contract, posing risks of fund misappropriation if developers act as agents. Professor Zhao Xiuchi from Capital University of Economics and Business noted that national laws do not impose a compulsory payment obligation for non-residential properties 1. Attorney Zhai Yujia explained that while some Beijing courts have upheld clauses allowing developers to collect these funds on behalf of owners, judicial support for refunds may arise if developers fail to transfer the funds or if standard contract terms are deemed flawed 1. In October 2026, following feedback via Beijing's 12345 hotline, the Daxing District Housing Commission confirmed it had summoned the developer, Beijing Shengxi Real Estate Co., Ltd., but lacked the authority to enforce refunds, advising affected parties to pursue legal remedies instead 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。