联合国关于致命性自主武器系统(LAWS)的国际谈判于2026年11月21日在日内瓦结束,与会各国未能就制定具有法律约束力的禁令达成协议 26。尽管会议旨在讨论如何监管具备自主杀伤能力的人工智能军事技术,但最终仅达成共识,决定在未来两年内即2028年前进一步细化相关规则并继续举行会谈 12358。这一结果被部分观察人士视为谈判的破裂或实质性进展的缺失,因为目前尚未确立走向具约束力条约的明确路径 257。
此次谈判由《特定常规武器公约》(CCW)框架下的128个缔约国参与,其中近100个国家曾呼吁进行具有法律约束力的协议谈判 26。会议主席朱利安·托尼(Julien Thoni)宣布各国同意启动国际文书的制定工作,但各方在强制禁令上存在严重分歧 2。美国、俄罗斯和以色列等技术持有国反对实施强制性限制,而超过100个国家推动制定新法律以应对自主武器带来的全新挑战 126。此外,秘书长古特雷斯、教皇利奥十四世以及红十字会均公开支持对这类武器实施禁令 27。
人权团体及非政府组织批评最终达成的授权方案过于薄弱,认为其削弱了谈判初衷 2。“停止杀手机器人”组织指责该结果导致授权内容被淡化,尽管此前有超过95个国家支持达成条约 2。未来生命研究所主席麦克斯·泰格马克(Max Tegmark)指出,“屠杀机器人已经到来”,并批评各国已连续14年仅停留在口头讨论阶段 6。鉴于乌克兰战争中已测试或部署自主武器系统,以及以色列和美国在加沙等地使用AI赋能瞄准系统的现实,巴西代表强调,这些武器已在使用中,国际社会在制定规范方面已经滞后 26。
Member states of the United Nations Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) concluded negotiations in Geneva on November 21, 2026, without reaching a legally binding ban on lethal autonomous weapons systems 2. While delegates agreed to continue discussions with the goal of elaborating new rules by 2028, no firm commitment was made to restrict the use of these AI-driven weapons 13458. The talks ended after one week, failing to achieve consensus on a mandatory treaty due to opposition from major military powers 6.
The outcome has drawn sharp criticism from human rights organizations and humanitarian groups who argue that the agreement amounts to a weakened mandate 2. Campaigners from the "Stop Killer Robots" coalition noted that over 95 countries had supported a stronger treaty framework, yet the final decision only required parties to work toward non-binding instruments 26. Conference President Julien Thoni announced that nations had agreed to launch the elaboration process for an international instrument, but this falls short of the immediate legal obligations sought by advocates 2. Bonnie Docherty, senior arms researcher at Human Rights Watch, stated that autonomous weapons require binding laws and argued that a treaty could be negotiated within 15 months, rejecting the five-year timeline proposed by the United States 6. Max Tegmark, president of the Future of Life Institute, emphasized the urgency of the situation by asserting, "Slaughterbots are already here," pointing out that governments have engaged in mere verbal discussions for 14 consecutive years 6.
Opposition to strict regulations came primarily from technology-holding states including the United States, Russia, and Israel, which resisted mandates that would constrain their military autonomy 2. Sources indicate that Russia employed blocking tactics to prevent the adoption of a binding declaration, while the US and other key nations were unwilling to commit to restrictions enforced by a global treaty 6. Despite this, more than 100 nations pushed for new laws, recognizing that autonomous systems present unprecedented challenges 6. A delegation from Brazil warned during the session, "These are not weapons of the future being discussed here, these are already in use and being further developed. We are late in developing these norms and rules to regulate these lethal autonomous weapons systems." 6 Seven countries—Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand, and Panama—had previously led efforts to negotiate a binding treaty within one year 6.
High-profile figures including UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, Pope Leo XIV, and the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) had previously called for legally binding rules within one year 27. However, the diplomatic gridlock persists amid evidence that autonomous technologies are already operational in conflict zones 26. Reports suggest that autonomous weapon systems have been tested or deployed in the war in Ukraine 2. Additionally, allegations state that Israel and the US have used AI-enabled targeting systems for tens of thousands of strikes in Gaza and Iran, resulting in mass casualties 6. The Pentagon reportedly struck over 1,000 targets on the first day of operations against Iran, aiming for US forces to execute 1,000 AI-assisted targeting decisions per hour 6.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。