Philip Young(50岁)承认对其前妻Joanne Young实施了数十项虐待罪行,其中包括下药使其处于无意识状态并邀请其他男子对其进行性侵 1。周四,四名陌生男子因对Joanne Young犯有性罪行被定罪 1。
案件审理过程中,被告辩称他们受到Philip Young的欺骗,误以为受害者同意,从而试图利用“合理相信受害者同意”或依赖“第三方同意”作为辩护理由 1。刑事大律师Kate Parker指出,《2003年性犯罪法》并未允许将同意外包给第三方,目前使用的是“真诚且合理地认为对方同意”这一辩护路径 1。工党议员Jess Phillips呼吁政府审查并收紧相关法律,以明确声明同意绝不能来自第三方 1。尽管英国司法部发言人重申现行法律已明确规定“没有人能代表别人同意”,但受害者及其支持者、律师和政客仍强烈批评此类辩护逻辑,主张通过立法加强原则以防止法律被滥用 1。
Four men were convicted on Thursday for sexual offenses committed against Joanne Young, a case that has intensified public scrutiny over the legal defense of "third-party consent" in the United Kingdom 1. The convictions stem from events orchestrated by Philip Young, 50, who admitted to dozens of abuse charges against his ex-wife, including drugging her into unconsciousness and inviting other men to sexually assault her 1. The defendants argued that they were deceived by Philip Young into believing that their victim had agreed to the acts, relying on a defense based on an honest and reasonable belief in consent provided by a third party 1.
Legal experts and politicians are now calling for legislative changes to explicitly prohibit anyone from giving consent on behalf of another person. Criminal barrister Kate Parker noted that while the Sexual Offences Act 2003 does not authorize outsourcing consent to a third party, the current legal framework allows for defenses based on a genuine and reasonable belief that the complainant consented 1. Labour MP Jess Phillips has urged the government to review and tighten these laws to ensure it is unequivocally stated that consent can never be given by a third party 1. Although a Ministry of Justice spokesperson reiterated that the law already clearly states no one can consent for another, campaigners argue that specific legislation is necessary to prevent such defenses from being abused 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。