近日,一则源自 Discord 通知的消息在 Hacker News 社区引发热议,该消息声称由未具名数学家与 AI 助手 Claude 共同完成了黎曼猜想的证明 1。根据声明内容,这一成果不仅涵盖了黎曼猜想本身,还成功解决了广义黎曼猜想(Generalized Riemann Hypothesis),并预计能够解决扩展黎曼猜想(Extended Riemann Hypothesis)1。报道指出,在这一合作过程中,Claude 在最终阶段超越了人类引导者,处于核心地位,而人类参与者则被描述为隐藏在边缘 1。
文章作者通过对比阿恩·兰德(Ayn Rand)笔下人类掌控自然的宏大叙事与此次声明中的人类处境,展开了尖锐批评 1。兰德曾描述阿波罗 11 号发射时人类所展现的伟大感,这与当前声明中“Claude 处于中心,人类隐藏在边缘”的状态形成鲜明反差 1。作者认为,这种将人类边缘化、视人为被动接受者的技术乐观主义倾向,实质上是对人类主体性和探索精神的背叛,构成了一种“背叛和投降” 1。
A recent claim that mathematicians, in collaboration with the AI assistant Claude, have proven the Riemann hypothesis and solved the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis has drawn sharp criticism for reflecting a "surrender" of human agency 1. The announcement, which originated from a Discord notification reading "they proved riemann :/", also stated that the Extended Riemann Hypothesis is expected to be resolved 1. According to the description of this collaboration, Claude surpassed its human guides during the final stages of the proof 1.
The commentary contrasts this development with Ayn Rand’s depiction of human grandeur during the Apollo 11 launch, highlighting how the current narrative places Claude at the center while humans remain hidden at the periphery 1. This dynamic is criticized as a betrayal of human subjectivity and exploratory spirit, suggesting that such technological optimism actually marginalizes people into passive recipients rather than active controllers of their environment 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。