澳大利亚独立国家安全立法监察员(INSLM)在完成为期15个月的审查后发布最终报告,建议对现行恐怖主义法律定义进行修改 1。该报告提议将关注重点从单一的“宗教”因素转向更广泛的“意识形态”范畴,旨在涵盖种族主义和民族主义等新兴威胁 1。现任监察员杰克·布莱特(Jake Blight)指出,这一调整并非缩小恐怖主义的定义范围,而是通过提供清晰的定义来应对新出现的威胁 1。他批评现行法律赋予极端分子虚假的宗教合法性,并建议将“意识形态”重新定义为任何关于世界或社会应如何被理解的信念或想法集合,无论其是否连贯 1。这一新的定义框架意在准确描述包括政治观点、信仰体系及群体优越感在内的多种信念形式 1。
数据表明,自2002年“9/11”事件后澳大利亚法律首次引入恐怖主义定义以来,相关法规至今未进行更新 1。然而,近期司法统计显示犯罪结构发生了显著变化:在2021年之前,仅有一例基于种族主义或民族主义意识形态的恐怖主义定罪;此后,此类案件占起诉总数的四分之一,但定罪成功率仅为50% 1。相比之下,涉及暴力圣战意识形态嫌疑人的定罪率高达84%,尽管其指控数量已降至今年总指控数的一半以下 1。此外,未成年人涉恐比例激增成为另一大隐患,历史上约8%的恐怖主义罪犯为儿童,而今年被控者中儿童占比约为三分之二,部分罪名下的未成年人比例甚至超过四分之三 1。为此,报告还建议引入独立的“威胁实施恐怖行为”罪名,并将人质劫持、破坏关键基础设施等行为纳入危害范围 1。
尽管多个穆斯林倡导组织如Australian Muslim Advocacy Network等联合发表声明支持该建议,认为现行措辞助长了伊斯兰恐惧症 1,但政府方面表现出明确的反对立场。澳大利亚内政部长托尼·伯克(Tony Burke)已明确排除移除定义中“宗教”一词的可能性 1。伯克表示,总理已明确指出不会进行此项更改,因此现行法律定义中的宗教要素将继续保留 1。
An independent review of Australia’s national security laws has recommended updating the legal definition of terrorism to focus on broader ideological motivations rather than religious ones. 1 The report, issued by the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM) after a 15-month examination, proposes defining "ideology" as any set of beliefs or ideas about how the world or society should be understood, regardless of their coherence. 1 INSLM Jake Blight stated that this change would not narrow the scope of terrorism but would instead provide a clearer framework to address emerging threats such as racism and nationalism. 1
The proposed shift aims to remove what Blight described as the false religious legitimacy granted to extremists under current laws. 1 This recommendation was welcomed by several Muslim advocacy groups, including the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network, who argued that the existing wording fuels Islamophobia. 1 However, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke rejected the suggestion to delete the word "religion" from the definition, noting that the Prime Minister had explicitly ruled out such a change. 1
The review highlighted significant changes in the landscape of terrorism prosecutions since the term "religious" was added to Australian law following the September 11 attacks in 2002. 1 Prior to 2021, only one conviction involved racist or nationalist ideologies; since then, such cases have accounted for a quarter of prosecutions, though with a success rate of just 50%. 1 In contrast, suspects driven by violent jihadist ideology maintain an 84% conviction rate and represent less than half of this year's charges. 1 Additionally, the report noted a sharp increase in child involvement, stating that while children historically made up about 8% of terrorism offenders, they now constitute approximately two-thirds of those charged this year, with some specific offenses seeing minors account for over three-quarters of defendants. 1 To address these trends, the INSLM suggested introducing standalone offenses for preparatory acts, such as threatening to commit terrorist acts, hostage-taking, and damaging critical infrastructure. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。