新西兰高等法院于11月19日作出判决,认定2025年《同工同酬法》修正案对女性主导职业构成歧视并造成实质性不利后果 1。Paul Radich法官在裁决中指出,修订后的法律侵犯了受保护的权利,然而依据新西兰宪法安排及《权利法案》,法院无权直接宣告立法无效,仅能发布“不一致性声明”以警示议会 1。这一司法结果凸显了新西兰人权保护机制高度依赖议会的自我约束,而非通过司法审查强制纠正 1。
此次争议源于政府对法律程序的快速推进,修正案于2025年5月6日以紧急状态引入,当日即完成三读且未经过专门委员会审查 1。新法取消了33项现有的同工同酬索赔案件,并提高了未来索赔的门槛 1。目前,国家党、行动党和新西兰优先党支持维持现状,而工党、绿党等反对力量则主张恢复原有法律框架 1。尽管议长已收紧议事规则,要求部长解释绕过常规审查的理由,但拥有多数席位的支持方仍可批准此类立法捷径,无需承担废除违权条款的法律义务 1。
A New Zealand High Court ruling has determined that the 2025 amendments to the Pay Equity Act constitute unjust discrimination against women 1. The judgment noted that the reforms eliminated 33 existing claims and raised the threshold for future ones 1. Justice Paul Radich stated on November 19 that the revised legislation creates substantive disadvantage and discriminates against occupations dominated by women 1. Despite this judicial finding of rights violation, the law remains active because constitutional constraints prevent courts from invalidating statutes solely for breaching protected rights under the Bill of Rights 1. Instead, the court issued a declaration of inconsistency, which serves as a formal notice rather than a legal nullification 1.
The controversy stems from the government’s procedural handling of the amendments, which were introduced on May 6, 2025, under an urgent state status that allowed all three readings to be completed on the same day without review by a select committee 1. This approach has drawn sharp political divisions: the National Party, ACT, and New Zealand First support maintaining the current amended framework, while opposition parties including Labour and the Greens advocate for restoring the original system 1. Although the Speaker of the House has tightened standing orders requiring ministers to justify bypassing standard scrutiny, a parliamentary majority retains the power to approve such expedited legislative processes 1. Consequently, the decision to uphold or rectify the discriminatory provisions rests entirely with Parliament, highlighting the heavy reliance on legislative self-restraint in New Zealand’s human rights protection mechanisms 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。