一项基于2023至24年澳大利亚Medicare数据的研究表明,专科医生首次问诊费用存在巨大差异,其中高达44.6%的费用变异由医生个人的定价选择决定 1。相比之下,专业领域类型仅解释了22.1%的变异,而地区因素的影响低至3.8% 1。该研究指出,尽管政府通过Medicare福利计划(MBS)设定了补贴标准,但澳大利亚并未对医生的实际收费上限进行监管,导致部分医生收费远超补贴额度,从而造成患者高额的自付费用 1。
数据显示,2023至24年间,专科医生首次问诊的平均费用为212澳元,而顾问医师(如心脏科和神经科医生)的平均费用达到246澳元 1。在MBS体系下,大多数专科医生首次问诊的补贴标准为95.10澳元,顾问医师的补贴标准则为167.75澳元 1。使用相同MBS项目代码的不同专科间收费差异显著:皮肤科医生的平均收费最高,约为253澳元,而眼科医生的平均收费约为189澳元 1。
与其他国家相比,英国实行支付工资制,加拿大、法国和德国均设有受监管的收费表,而澳大利亚不设定医生收费上限 1。针对这一现状,研究人员Yuting Zhang、Chenhao Liang和Jongsay Yong提出改革建议,主张根据实际运营成本更新日程费,并将全额回扣资格与医生是否收取接近该标准的费用挂钩 1。此外,他们建议利用新法律升级“医疗费用查询工具”(Medical Costs Finder),使其能够公开显示单个医生的具体收费标准 1。
A recent analysis of Australian Medicare data from 2023–24 reveals that the wide disparity in fees charged by specialists for initial consultations is primarily driven by individual doctors’ pricing decisions rather than differences in specialty, patient health status, or geographic location 1. The study found that personal physician factors accounted for 44.6% of the variation in costs, making it the single largest determinant 1. In comparison, the type of medical specialty explained 22.1% of the variance, while regional factors contributed only 3.8% 1.
Despite these variations, government-set subsidy levels under the Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS) remain standardized, with most specialist initial consultation subsidies fixed at AUD 95.10 and consultant-level services such as cardiology and neurology subsidized at AUD 167.75 1. However, average actual charges significantly exceed these benchmarks: general specialists charge an average of AUD 212 per initial visit, while consultants charge approximately AUD 246 1. Notably, dermatologists command the highest average fees at around AUD 253, whereas ophthalmologists charge about AUD 189, even though both groups bill using identical MBS item codes 1.
The research highlights that Australia lacks regulatory caps on doctor fees, unlike peer nations such as the United Kingdom, which pays salaries, and Canada, France, and Germany, which maintain regulated fee schedules 1. This absence of price controls allows some practitioners to set rates far above the subsidized amount, resulting in substantial out-of-pocket costs for patients 1. To address this issue, the authors propose linking full rebate eligibility to reasonable charging practices, specifically recommending updates to scheduled fees based on actual operational costs so that only doctors charging near those standards receive complete rebates 1. Additionally, they suggest utilizing new legislative tools to upgrade the "Medical Costs Finder" website, enabling greater transparency by displaying specific fees charged by individual doctors 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。