据报道,美国询问乌克兰是否愿意将顿涅茨克省割让给俄罗斯,以换取加入北约或获得安全保障 1。目前,俄罗斯控制卢甘斯克大部分及顿涅茨克大片区域,但乌克兰仍控制克拉马托尔斯克和斯洛维扬斯克等主要城市 1。针对这一提议,乌克兰总统泽连斯基强调目前无具体提案;任何协议将“不承认俄罗斯对这些领土的占领”;且不能独自做决定,需与盟友协商 1。
美方构想的保障机制参考《北大西洋公约》第4条和第5条,但不设想美军驻扎乌克兰本土,而是倾向于类似以色列的双边保障模式 1。对此,俄罗斯发言人佩斯科夫表示出于和平进程利益,不披露美俄会谈细节 1。然而,专家普遍质疑此类“土地换安全”协议的有效性,担心重蹈布达佩斯备忘录的覆辙 1。专家 Oleksandr Kraiev 认为这可能导致“第二个布达佩斯备忘录”,指出至少半数北约成员对乌入约持保留态度 1。历史背景显示,1994年《布达佩斯备忘录》未包含英美保卫乌克兰的承诺 1。法律学者 Oleksandr Khara 指出,割让领土违反乌克兰宪法,破坏“边界不得以武力重新划定”的世界秩序,公投将设立危险先例 1。
民调数据显示多数乌克兰人反对撤军。基辅国际社会学研究所(KISS)调查显示,61%受访者坚决拒绝从乌控顿巴斯地区撤军,35%勉强接受土地换安全交易 1。分析人士 Sergiy Solodkyy 建议模仿德国案例,即乌克兰在加入北约时仅保护其实际控制线,不放弃主权主张 1。
Reports indicate that the United States has inquired whether Ukraine would be willing to cede control of the Donetsk region in exchange for NATO membership or comparable security guarantees. 1 This proposal comes as Russia currently controls most of the Luhansk region and a significant portion of Donetsk, while Ukraine maintains authority over key cities such as Kramatorsk and Sloviansk. 1 Although no formal agreement is yet on the table, the suggestion has sparked intense debate regarding sovereignty, international law, and the reliability of Western security commitments. 1
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated that there is currently no specific proposal, emphasizing that any future deal would not involve recognizing Russian occupation of these territories. 1 He further noted that such decisions cannot be made unilaterally and would require consultation with allies. 1 The U.S. concept reportedly draws inspiration from Articles 4 and 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty but does not envision stationing American troops within Ukrainian borders; instead, it leans toward a bilateral guarantee model similar to that offered to Israel. 1 Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov declined to disclose details of U.S.-Russia talks, citing interests in the peace process. 1
Experts and legal analysts have raised substantial concerns about the viability and legality of such an arrangement. Oleksandr Kraiev warned that this could result in a "second Budapest Memorandum," noting that at least half of NATO members remain hesitant about Ukraine's accession, while recalling that the 1994 memorandum did not include binding defense promises from the UK and US. 1 Oleksandr Khara pointed out that ceding territory violates the Ukrainian constitution and undermines the global order established on the principle that borders must not be redrawn by force, arguing that a referendum on such terms would set a dangerous precedent. 1 Public sentiment also reflects strong opposition, with a survey by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology (KISS) revealing that 61% of respondents firmly reject withdrawing from government-controlled Donbas, whereas only 35% are reluctantly open to a land-for-security trade. 1 Alternatively, expert Sergiy Solodkyy suggested adopting a German-style model where Ukraine joins NATO with protections limited to its current line of control, without relinquishing sovereign claims to occupied areas. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。