瑞士非营利组织Quad9宣布撤出其在法国的免费公共DNS解析服务 1。这一决定源于法国法院对其未能拦截涉嫌版权侵权域名的行为处以每日财务处罚 1。此类强制公共DNS进行内容审查的做法并非孤例,此前Cisco也曾因类似原因从法国、葡萄牙及比利时(暂时)撤出了其OpenDNS解析器 1。最近,比利时法院进一步下令,若Cloudflare、Google和Cisco未能在2027年1月初之前通过其公共解析器封锁指定网站,将面临巨额罚款 1。目前,这三家公司已就比利时的命令提起上诉,并希望在年底前解决此事,以避免重演Quad9被迫退出市场的局面 1。
作为该事件的评论方,Cloudflare指出在DNS层面实施封锁是一种无效的“钝器”,因为它只能屏蔽整个域名而无法精准针对特定文件,且极易通过更换解析器或直接使用IP地址访问来绕过 1。文章强调,这种基础设施层面的强制干预不仅破坏互联网的隐私与稳定性,还可能导致依赖Quad9等服务的政府机构、学校、医院和公用事业设施在不知情的情况下遭遇断网风险 1。Cloudflare于2018年4月推出了以速度快和不收集用户数据著称的1.1.1.1公共DNS解析器 1。该公司呼吁政策制定者应转变思路,转而要求托管服务商删除侵权内容,而非惩罚提供基础网络设施的提供者 1。
Quad9, a Swiss non-profit organization, has announced its withdrawal from providing public DNS resolution services in France. The decision stems from the inability to bear the heavy financial penalties imposed by French courts for failing to block domains suspected of copyright infringement 1. This move highlights the growing tension between internet infrastructure providers and judicial orders requiring them to act as content censorship gatekeepers at the DNS level 1.
The incident is not isolated; Cisco previously exited the OpenDNS resolver market in France, Portugal, and temporarily Belgium for similar reasons 1. Recently, Belgian courts issued orders threatening massive fines against Cloudflare, Google, and Cisco if they do not begin blocking specific websites via their public resolvers by early January 2027 1. In response, these companies have filed appeals aiming to resolve the matter before the end of the year to prevent a recurrence of the situation seen with Quad9 1.
Cloudflare, which authored the analysis surrounding this issue, argues that mandatory DNS-level blocking is an ineffective "blunt instrument." Such measures can only block entire domains rather than specific files and are easily bypassed by users switching resolvers or accessing sites directly via IP addresses 1. Furthermore, the company contends that forcing public DNS interception undermines internet privacy and stability, potentially causing disconnections for essential services such as government agencies, schools, hospitals, and utilities that rely on these free resolvers without prior notice 1. Cloudflare launched its 1.1.1.1 public DNS resolver in April 2018, emphasizing its speed and commitment to not collecting user data 1. The article calls on policymakers to shift their focus toward requiring hosting providers to remove infringing content directly, rather than penalizing infrastructure providers who lack the technical means to effectively police the open internet 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。