英国下议院司法委员会举行听证会,探讨施暴者如何利用禁令、保密协议以及针对公众参与的战略性诉讼(SLAPPs)等手段压制性侵受害者发声 1。这一议题在Russell Brand定罪和David Walliams被指控不当行为后引发关注 1。
幸存者组织Gemini Project的联合创始人Verity Nevitt指出,此类通过巨额费用迫使受害者沉默的行为被视为对现实的扭曲,是“终极形式的煤气灯效应” 1。Nevitt以自身经历为例说明该现象:她和姐妹因在社交媒体上指认一名涉嫌强奸的男子而被起诉,尽管警方已撤销相关案件,但该男子仍提起诉讼,导致姐妹俩面临高昂的法律成本 1。律师告知Nevitt姐妹,若要进行下一次庭审需筹措10万英镑 1。
在法律专家看来,英国在保护公共利益言论方面存在显著缺陷。Rupert Cowper-Coles指出,英国是西方民主国家中的“主要异类”,缺乏通用的反SLAPP法律,现有规定仅覆盖经济犯罪相关的披露 1。Jennifer Robinson和Harriet Wistrich等法律人士认为,当前法律环境对女性遭受暴力的公共讨论产生了寒蝉效应,呼吁英国出台全面的反SLAPP法案,并主张实施严格费用封顶或扩大反SLAPP法的适用范围,以保护女性免受暴力侵害及进行相关公共讨论的权利 1。
The UK’s Justice Committee has been told that employing legal tactics such as injunctions, non-disclosure agreements, and Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (SLAPPs) to silence sexual abuse survivors constitutes the “ultimate form of gaslighting” 1. This testimony emerged during a hearing prompted by recent high-profile cases, including Russell Brand’s conviction and allegations against David Walliams, which brought scrutiny to how perpetrators leverage the justice system to suppress victims’ voices 1. Verity Nevitt, co-founder of the advocacy group Gemini Project, argued that these lawsuits distort reality and coerce silence through financial intimidation 1.
Nevitt illustrated her point with the experience of her sister and herself, who faced legal action from a man they had identified on social media as a suspected rapist 1. Although police dropped their investigation into the man, he continued to pursue civil litigation against the sisters, resulting in mounting costs 1. Lawyers advised the Nevitt sisters that they would need to raise £100,000 solely to cover expenses for the next court hearing, highlighting the prohibitive financial burden placed on those speaking out about violence 1.
Legal experts appearing before the committee emphasized that the UK is a “major outlier” among Western democracies due to its lack of comprehensive anti-SLAPP legislation, which currently only covers disclosures related to economic crime 1. Rupert Cowper-Coles noted this significant gap in protection 1. Meanwhile, barristers Jennifer Robinson and Harriet Wistrich warned that existing laws create a chilling effect on public discourse regarding violence against women 1. They advocated for stricter cost-capping measures or an expansion of anti-SLAPP provisions to safeguard free speech and protect survivors from retaliatory legal actions 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。