美国前总统唐纳德·特朗普声称,在阿拉斯加州参议员席位计票期间,选民因同名候选人而投错了共和党现任参议员丹·S·沙利文(Dan S Sullivan)1。这一说法源于此次选举中出现了另一位名为丹尼尔·J·沙利文二世(Daniel J Sullivan Jr)的候选人,尽管其得票率仅为1.65%且排名最后,但争议随之而起1。《纽约时报》此前曾报道指民主党活动人士试图招募包括沙利文二世在内的“搅局”候选人以制造混淆,但该消息未经独立核实,且相关方均予以否认1。针对特朗普提出的舞弊及混淆指控,BBC Verify的数据分析显示这些说法缺乏事实依据1。截至周一,在已统计97%选票的情况下,民主党候选人玛丽·佩尔托拉(Mary Peltola)以49.94%的得票率保持领先1。
阿拉斯加州采用排序复选制,若首轮无候选人获得超过50%的偏好票,则进行后续轮次的淘汰与重新分配1。为了验证“选民混淆说”,分析师模拟了将两位沙利文的选票合并计算的情景,结果显示即便合并所有支持丹·S·沙利文和丹尼尔·J·沙利文二世的选票,仍无法超越佩尔托拉的领先优势1。进一步的数据剖析削弱了混淆假设的可信度:38%首选沙利文二世的选民未填写有效的第二选择,而在填写了第二选择的选民中,29%将其列为对佩尔托拉的支持,仅有15%将其列为对现任参议员沙利文的支持1。
Former President Donald Trump has alleged that voters in the ongoing Alaska Senate race were confused by the presence of a candidate with a similar name to the incumbent Republican, Senator Dan Sullivan 1. However, an analysis conducted by BBC Verify suggests that even if the votes for both Sullivans were combined, Democratic candidate Mary Peltola would still maintain her lead 1. As of Monday, Peltola held 49.94% of the vote count, with 97% of ballots tallied 1. The dispute centers on whether Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., who finished last with only 1.65% of the vote, inadvertently split support away from the incumbent due to voter mix-ups 1.
Data from Alaska’s ranked-choice voting system undermines the theory that widespread confusion benefited the Democrats 1. In this system, if no candidate secures more than 50% of first-preference votes in the initial round, subsequent rounds eliminate lower-ranked candidates and redistribute their ballots based on voters’ next choices 1. BBC Verify found that among those who initially voted for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., 38% did not provide a valid second choice, while 29% listed Mary Peltola as their second preference 1. Only 15% of these voters ranked the incumbent Senator Dan Sullivan as their second choice, indicating that few of his supporters mistakenly voted for the other Sullivan 1.
The controversy was further fueled by a report from The New York Times, which stated that Democratic activists had attempted to recruit "spoiler" candidates, including Daniel J. Sullivan Jr 1. This claim has been denied by the parties involved and was not independently verified by BBC 1. Despite these allegations and Trump’s assertions of electoral irregularities, the available data shows that Peltola’s position remains strong regardless of how the second Sullivan’s votes are distributed or counted 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。