一项由Unearthed和Public Eye开展的调查数据显示,去年巴西卫生部记录在案的2857起涉及具体产品的农药中毒报告中,有1605起与欧洲化工企业销售的品牌有关1。在这1605起案件中,1420例被归类为确认中毒,另有1108例被记录为暴露情况1。值得注意的是,约三分之一的案例涉及因健康和环境风险而在欧盟被禁止使用的化学物质,但这些物质仍由瑞士先正达、德国巴斯夫和拜耳等公司在欧洲生产并出口至法规相对宽松的国家1。
涉事产品主要包括含敌草快(diquat)的Reglone、含氰胺(cyanamide)的Dormex以及含草铵膦(glufosinate)的Finale等1。其中,先正达在英国哈德斯菲尔德工厂生产的Reglone所含成分已于2020年在英国禁用;德国Alzchem生产、巴斯夫分销的Dormex于2008年被欧盟禁用;巴斯夫的Finale则于2018年被欧盟禁用1。此外,拜耳旗下含有草甘膦的Roundup也被列入调查范围1。在具体品牌提及次数上,先正达的产品被提及425次,巴斯夫的产品被提及179次1。
调查指出,这些欧洲公司的产品导致32人死亡,其中26起案件被记录为自杀1。以先正达的Reglone为例,该产品在巴西造成Nelson Castoldi误服后两天内死亡,去年涉及该产品的案件共75例,远高于2018年至2022年五年间的36例1。绿色和平组织批评这种现象为“致命的双重标准”,并要求禁止出口那些在欧盟已被禁用的农药1。
面对指控,相关公司均予以回应并强调其合规性。先正达指出近半数案件未确认为中毒,并对报告的分类方式提出质疑1。拜耳方面表示数据可靠性存疑,并称部分涉案产品为仿冒品1。巴斯夫虽然对调查结果表示关注,但认为多起事件属于故意滥用,并强调公司严格遵守当地法规且提供安全培训1。
Investigative data reveals that products from major European chemical companies were identified in more than half of the pesticide poisoning reports filed in Brazil last year. According to figures from the Brazilian Health Ministry, out of 2,857 incidents where specific commercial products were named, 1,605 involved brands sold by European firms 1. The report categorizes these cases into 1,420 confirmed poisonings and 1,108 instances of exposure 1. Among the implicated entities, Swiss company Syngenta was mentioned in 425 cases, while German firm BASF appeared in 179 reports 1. These incidents resulted in 32 deaths, with 26 of those fatalities recorded as suicides 1.
The investigation highlights a regulatory discrepancy, noting that approximately one-third of the cases involved chemicals banned within the European Union due to health and environmental risks, yet still produced and exported by companies such as Syngenta, BASF, and Bayer 1. Specific products cited include Syngenta’s Reglone, manufactured at its Huddersfield plant in the UK and containing diquat, a substance banned in Britain in 2020; BASF’s Finale, which contains glufosinate, an EU-banned chemical since 2018; and Dormex, produced by Germany’s Alzchem and distributed by BASF, containing cyanamide, prohibited in the EU since 2008 1. Bayer’s Roundup, containing glyphosate, was also named in the reports 1. The use of diquat-containing products saw a significant rise, with 75 cases recorded last year compared to 36 cases over the five-year period from 2018 to 2022 1. One tragic example involves Nelson Castoldi, who died two days after accidentally ingesting Reglone in Brazil 1.
Greenpeace has condemned the situation as a "lethal double standard," calling for a ban on the export of pesticides prohibited in the EU 1. In response, the companies disputed the interpretation of the data. Syngenta argued that nearly half of the reported cases were not classified as poisonings and questioned the categorization within the reports 1. Bayer stated that the reliability of the data was questionable and noted that some products might have been counterfeits 1. BASF expressed concern but attributed many incidents to intentional misuse, emphasizing their compliance with local regulations and provision of safety training 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。