国际刑警组织(INTERPOL)与联合国毒品和犯罪问题办公室(UNODC)联合发布报告,对执法部门在审讯嫌疑人时使用神经监测技术的做法发出严厉警告 1。该报告由神经技术与法律中心主任、同时担任此次合作项目专家顾问组成员的 Allan McCay 主要撰写 1。报告指出,尽管阿联酋和印度等地的部分警力已尝试利用该技术检测嫌疑人的“有罪知识” (guilty knowledge),但其科学有效性尚未得到证实 1。这种未经证实的技术应用可能侵犯包括隐私权、免于自证其罪权以及思想自由在内的多项核心人权 1。
在具体司法实践层面,2010年印度最高法院裁定非自愿使用该技术的证据不可采,但据报道当地警方仍在调查中使用相关手段 1。在澳大利亚新南威尔士州,《测谎仪法》明确禁止使用测谎仪,这可能涵盖神经测谎测试,但未涵盖基于图像识别的神经检测方法 1。针对这一情况,澳大利亚人权委员会建议暂停使用该技术,并等待澳大利亚法律改革委员会进行进一步审查 1。报告强调,为确保神经技术的发展加强而非削弱法治,需要重点关注“早期意识、科学严谨性、法律清晰度和机构准备度” 1。
A joint report by INTERPOL and the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) has issued a stark warning regarding the legal and ethical risks associated with using neuro-monitoring technologies during police interrogations 1. The report highlights that while some law enforcement agencies in countries such as the United Arab Emirates and India have attempted to use these tools to detect "guilty knowledge," their scientific validity remains unproven 1. Consequently, the application of such technology poses significant threats to core human rights, including privacy, the right against self-incrimination, and freedom of thought 1.
Despite a 2010 ruling by India’s Supreme Court declaring evidence obtained through non-consensual use of this technology inadmissible, reports indicate that police forces continue to employ it in investigations 1. In Australia, the situation varies by jurisdiction; the New South Wales Lie Detectors Act prohibits the use of lie detectors, which may cover neural lie detection but not image-recognition-based neural tests 1. Furthermore, the Australian Human Rights Commission has recommended suspending the use of such technologies pending a review by the Australian Law Reform Commission 1. Allan McCay, the lead author of the report and director of the Centre for Neuroscience & Law, served as an expert advisory panel member for the UNODC-INTERPOL collaboration 1. He emphasized that ensuring neurotechnology strengthens rather than undermines the rule of law requires early awareness, scientific rigor, legal clarity, and institutional readiness 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。