南威尔士警察内部披露的数据揭示,当地执法部门在使用人工智能面部识别技术时存在显著的种族失衡现象 1。2025年全年,警官共对257名成年人和14名儿童(其中包括两名10岁以下者)发起了面部扫描 1。数据显示,被选中进行检查的人中有24%来自少数族裔,而该群体仅占辖区总人口的7%,这意味着少数族裔被扫描的可能性是白人的四倍 1。这一比例甚至高于逮捕数据中的代表性,因为在该警察管辖区内,少数族裔被捕者占比仅为11% 1。涉及的技术名为“Neoface”,其功能是将智能手机捕捉的面部图像与拘留所照片及其他数据库进行匹配 1。
民权组织对此表示强烈担忧,批评这种侵入性生物识别工具不成比例地针对少数群体,并可能强化现有偏见 1。Big Brother Watch研究主管Jake Hurfurt称:“这些数据表明侵入性生物识别工具正被用来不成比例地针对少数族裔社区……令人震惊的是,非白人遭受面部扫描的比率远高于按地区人口结构或被捕人员构成预期的水平。” 1 Race Equality First首席执行官Aliya Mohammed表示:“面部识别并非中立,因为它使用人工智能。如果现有偏见影响谁被拦截和扫描,技术可能会强化甚至放大不平等。” 1 实际案例显示,26岁的Alvi Choudhury曾因软件将其误认为另一南亚裔嫌疑人,而在从未去过的城市被捕 1。在统计结果方面,若匹配成功,48%的情况导致逮捕,三分之一没有进一步行动 1。
面对争议,英国内政部本月早些时候宣布成立新的面部识别监管机构,有权在警方违反规则时停止其使用该技术 1。尽管内政大臣视该技术为破案的重大突破,但警方已承认数据存在失衡问题并表示正在审查 1。此外,伦敦大都会警察局也在试验类似系统,其中克洛伊登试点项目(2025年10月至2026年3月期间)导致了173人被捕 1。
Internal data from South Wales Police reveals that ethnic minority individuals are four times more likely to be subjected to AI-driven facial recognition checks compared to their share of the population. While this group constitutes only 7% of the local population, they accounted for 24% of those selected for scanning by the force’s "Neoface" algorithm, which matches smartphone-captured images against custody photos and other databases 1. This disparity exceeds even arrest rates within the jurisdiction, where ethnic minorities represent 11% of those detained 1. The findings have triggered severe concerns regarding algorithmic racial bias, with civil rights organizations arguing that such invasive biometric tools disproportionately target minority communities and risk leading to wrongful arrests 1.
Critics emphasize that the technology is not neutral despite its reliance on artificial intelligence. Aliya Mohammed, CEO of Race Equality First, stated that if existing biases influence who is stopped and scanned, the technology may reinforce or amplify inequality 1. Jake Hurfurt, research director at Big Brother Watch, described the statistics as "shocking," noting that non-white individuals face facial scans at rates far exceeding what would be expected based on regional demographics or arrest compositions 1. The potential for error was highlighted by the case of Alvi Choudhury, a 26-year-old man arrested in a city he had never visited after software misidentified him as another suspect of South Asian descent 1. In 2025 alone, officers initiated facial scans on 257 adults and 14 children, including two under the age of 10 1. Among successful matches, 48% resulted in an arrest, while one-third led to no further action 1.
Home Secretary views the technology as a major breakthrough in solving crimes. However, police have acknowledged the imbalance in the data and indicated that it is under review 1. To address growing regulatory concerns, the Home Office announced earlier this month the establishment of a new oversight body for facial recognition systems, empowered to halt police usage of the technology if rules are violated 1. Similar trials are underway elsewhere, including a project by the Metropolitan Police in Croydon running from October 2025 to March 2026, which reportedly led to 173 arrests 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。