英国前内阁大臣艾伦·米尔本主导了一项针对青年失业及脱离教育问题的政府审查,其报告预计将与蒂姆斯审查相结合,于明年春季形成白皮书并进而成为新的福利法案 1。数据显示,目前处于失业和失学状态的年轻人接近100万,若不加干预,预计到2030年代初这一数字可能攀升至125万 1。与此同时,英国青年未受教育、就业或培训(NEET)的比例已达13%,为2014年以来的最高水平 2。该审查旨在重构针对年轻人的社会保障体系 1。
米尔本在报告中提出了一个核心道德论点以缓和工党内部对削减福利的抵触情绪:政府花在年轻人福利上的资金是用于支持他们就业资金的25倍 12。为此,报告建议废除25岁以下人群的现有健康福利(包括现有申领者),并建立独立的青年福利体系和机会服务局,通过更严格的资格标准换取强力就业支持 12。具体目标是将上述支出比例调整为2比1,并承诺每年帮助约60万25岁以下青年进入教育、就业或培训领域,力求在2036年将NEET率降至5% 2。作为交换,建议政府在短期内投入数亿英镑用于重返工作岗位的支持,以换取长期的福利节省和税收增加 1。
尽管福利大臣帕特·麦克法登强调这是“给年轻人的新协议”而非单纯的公关手段,但该提案仍面临多方质疑 1。工党左翼议员包括纳迪亚·惠托姆等联名警告,削减福利可能导致更多青年陷入贫困,指出年轻人需要的是机会而非惩罚 2。反对派影子卫生大臣海伦·惠特利则批评该方案过于谨慎且导致政府支出增加数十亿,认为至少三年内不会对现有领取福利的青年产生实际影响 2。对此,安迪·伯纳姆承诺若采纳该计划,将结合对福利制度的彻底反思,并在儿童早期介入以解决青年失业问题 2。
Former Cabinet minister Alan Milburn has published a government review urging the UK Labour administration to overhaul welfare support for young people, arguing that the current system disproportionately favors benefit payments over employment assistance. The report highlights that nearly one million young individuals are currently neither in education, employment, or training (NEET), with this rate reaching 13%, the highest level since 2014 2. If no intervention occurs, projections suggest this number could rise to 1.25 million by the early 2030s 1. A central finding cited by Milburn is that the government spends £25 on youth welfare benefits for every £1 invested in helping them find work 12.
To address this imbalance, the review recommends abolishing existing health-related benefits for those under the age of 25 and replacing them with a distinct, stricter eligibility framework coupled with intensive job support 12. The proposal aims to adjust the spending ratio from 25:1 to 2:1 by investing hundreds of millions of pounds in return-to-work programs, which Milburn argues will yield long-term savings and increased tax revenue 12. The strategy includes establishing an independent opportunity service and setting a target to reduce the NEET rate to 5% by 2036, assisting approximately 600,000 young people annually into education, employment, or training 2.
The report’s recommendations are set to be integrated with the forthcoming Timms review to form a white paper next spring, which will serve as the basis for new welfare legislation 1. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden characterized the initiative as a "new deal" for young people rather than a mere public relations exercise 1. Meanwhile, Andy Burnham has pledged that if the plan is adopted, it will be accompanied by a comprehensive rethinking of the welfare system and early interventions for children to prevent future unemployment 2.
Despite the proposed reforms, the report has faced scrutiny from various political quarters. Labour MPs on the left, including Nadia Whittome, have jointly warned that cutting benefits could drive more young people into poverty, asserting that youth require opportunities rather than penalties 2. Opposition Shadow Health Minister Helen Whately criticized the scheme as overly cautious, noting it would increase government spending by billions while failing to provide tangible impact for existing claimants for at least three years 2.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。