面对活动人士和家长团体对法律保护措施被削弱的批评,英格兰政府正考虑在特殊教育需求(SEND)改革中做出重大让步,可能引入新的独立上诉途径。1 教育大臣露西·鲍威尔向议员暗示将采取此类措施,并确认修改上诉程序是确保相关机制到位的关键部分。1 此次政策调整的背景在于,政府计划用由学校管理的“个人支持计划”(ISPs)取代目前广泛使用的“教育与保健计划”(EHCPs),这一变动限制了家长通过高等法院法庭进行上诉的权利,从而引发担忧。1
潜在的新方案包括两条独立的救济渠道:一是允许向地方政府与社会护理申诉专员投诉;二是设立模仿学校开除上诉机制的独立审查小组。1 现行SEND法庭系统已不堪重负,数据显示,截至6月的三个月内,高等法院收到8,800起上诉,案件积压量升至18,000起,较2025年增加了31%。1 此外,法庭最终口头听证会的平均等待时间已超过18个月,这意味着现在提起的诉讼预计要到2028年5月才能审理。1 尽管争议激烈,政府的法案及其对SEND白皮书咨询的正式回应预计要到明年年初才会就绪。1
The UK government is weighing significant concessions to its proposed overhaul of special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) provisions in England, following intense criticism from activists and parent groups over weakened legal protections 1. Education Secretary Lucy Powell indicated that new independent avenues for appeals could be introduced to address concerns that the current system leaves families with insufficient recourse when their child’s support plans are downgraded 1. This potential shift comes as the Department for Education prepares to respond to a consultation on the SEND White Paper, with legislative changes not expected until early next year 1.
Central to the controversy is the proposal to replace widespread Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs) with school-managed Individual Support Plans (ISPs), a change that limits parents’ ability to appeal decisions to the Upper Tribunal 1. In response to these restrictions, officials are considering two primary options for new redress mechanisms: filing complaints with the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman or establishing an independent review panel modeled after school exclusion appeal processes 1. Powell confirmed to MPs that revising the appeal procedure is a critical component of ensuring the safeguarding mechanisms are properly established, stating simply, “wait and see” regarding the final form of these changes 1.
The urgency of reforming the appeal process is underscored by severe bottlenecks in the existing judicial system. The Upper Tribunal received 8,800 appeals in the three months leading up to June, while the total backlog has risen to 18,000 cases, marking a 31% increase compared to 2025 levels 1. Current average wait times for a final oral hearing at the SEND tribunal exceed 18 months, meaning any new appeal filed today would likely not be heard until May 2028 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。