澳大利亚维多利亚州及其他地区存在被监禁女性在分娩期间仍被束缚于镣铐和手铐中的现象,这一做法虽在当前法律框架下未被完全禁止,但已被指违反国际人权准则并危及母婴健康 1。尽管《澳大利亚矫正指导原则》规定分娩期间不使用约束器具,但该指南未明确涵盖怀孕期,且各州现行政策允许在总经理批准及“特殊情况”下使用约束具 1。2017年,维多利亚州监察员已将孕期及分娩期间使用镣铐列为重大关切事项 1。
针对这一争议性实践,独立参议员Lidia Thorpe曾提出联邦法案以禁止分娩期间的束缚行为,但该法案在2024年10月遭到工党和联盟党的共同阻止,两党理由是此事属于州管辖范畴 1。研究指出,没有证据表明被监禁女性在分娩期间或之后构成更高的逃跑风险或对他人形成不可接受的安全威胁 1。据澳大利亚的最佳估计,约有2%至6%的女性在监禁期间怀孕,其中原住民女性的比例更高 1。受访者Liliana的经历显示,她在怀孕约10周时进入维多利亚州最高安全级别女子监狱,直至生子全程均受到束缚 1。该做法被认为违反了《公民权利和政治权利国际公约》第7条和第10条以及联合国《曼谷规则》,相关呼声要求通过立法终结这种羞辱性且不安全的实践 1。
Incarcerated women in Australia, including those in Victoria’s highest-security prisons, continue to give birth while restrained by shackles and handcuffs, a practice that violates international human rights standards and poses risks to maternal and infant health. 1 One affected individual, identified as Liliana*, entered a Victorian prison at approximately 10 weeks pregnant and remained under restraint throughout her pregnancy until childbirth. 1 The Victorian Inspectorate had already flagged the use of restraints during pregnancy and labor as a major concern in 2017, highlighting the long-standing nature of this issue within the state correctional system. 1
Although the Australian Correctional Guidelines specify that no restraints should be used during delivery, they do not explicitly prohibit them during pregnancy, allowing state policies to permit their use with the approval of a general manager in "special circumstances." 1 Research indicates that best estimates show between 2% and 6% of incarcerated women are pregnant, with Indigenous women representing a higher proportion. 1 There is no evidence suggesting that imprisoned women pose a greater flight risk or an unacceptable threat to others during or after childbirth, undermining the security justification for such practices. 1 Consequently, the practice contravenes Article 7 and Article 10 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, as well as the United Nations’ Bangkok Rules. 1
Efforts to ban this practice at the federal level have been stalled by political maneuvering. In October 2024, both the Labor Party and the Coalition blocked a federal bill introduced by independent Senator Lidia Thorpe that sought to prohibit the restraint of incarcerated women during childbirth. 1 The parties justified their opposition by arguing that the matter falls under state jurisdiction, leaving the shaming and unsafe practice legally permissible despite widespread criticism from international bodies and domestic oversight agencies. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。