Alpha School是一家由人工智能驱动的私立学校网络,其年学费高达7.5万美元 1。尽管获得了硅谷投资者及美国教育部官员的支持,内部数据显示该校的教学效果并未达到预期目标 1。仅有42%的学生实现了在数学和阅读上学习速度翻倍的目标 1。具体而言,约一半处于K-8阶段的学生未达到数学目标,而约五分之一未达到阅读目标 1。
该学校的扩张模式及其对AI工具的依赖引发了广泛争议。目前,超过2,600名得克萨斯州和南卡罗来纳州的公立学校学生正在使用Alpha的平台 1。美国教育部长Linda McMahon曾称Alpha模式为“长期以来教育界最令人兴奋的事情” 1。然而,前员工透露Alpha的AI生成了有缺陷的课程计划,这些课程有时被内部文件描述为“弊大于利”,并涉嫌侵权 1。此外,多项研究及专家观点指出,过度依赖AI工具可能导致学生批判性思维和持续阅读能力下降 1。一项针对中国中部26,811名中学生的研究显示,使用生成式AI后作业分数上升18%,但闭卷考试分数却下降了20% 1。
Alpha School, a private network driven by artificial intelligence with annual tuition fees reaching $75,000, has revealed internal data showing that only 42% of its students achieved the goal of doubling their learning speed in mathematics and reading 1. Specifically, approximately half of the students at the K-8 level failed to meet the mathematical targets, while about one-fifth did not reach the reading goals 1. Despite these performance shortfalls, the institution has attracted support from Silicon Valley investors and U.S. Department of Education officials, including Secretary Linda McMahon, who described the Alpha model as "the most exciting thing happening in education in a long time" 1.
The controversy surrounding Alpha’s efficacy extends beyond its private enrollment figures. More than 2,600 public school students in Texas and South Carolina are currently utilizing the platform, even as former employees have disclosed that AI-generated lesson plans contained errors and were sometimes internally described as causing more harm than good 1. Concerns over potential copyright infringement in these materials have also been raised by staff 1. Broader academic research suggests that reliance on such tools may undermine critical thinking; a study involving 26,811 middle school students in central China found that while generative AI use led to an 18% increase in homework scores, it resulted in a 20% decline in closed-book exam performance 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。