2026年11月,谷歌发布了一项引发争议的政策,规定若学校要求在学生使用的旗舰搜索工具中关闭“AI概览”(AI Overviews)功能,这些机构将完全失去对谷歌搜索的访问权限 1。这一“全有或全无”的策略迅速招致家长、教育工作者及政界人士的强烈反对与担忧 1。家长权益倡导者朱迪·卡雷昂表示:“家长们很生气。他们非常生气。” 1
针对该策略背后的动机,前谷歌员工特蕾西·皮佐提出了法律层面的理论分析。她指出,谷歌刚在反垄断诉讼中获胜,法官裁定“搜索与人工智能是集成产品”,如果允许学校单独关闭AI功能,将成为二者可分离的证据,从而动摇谷歌胜诉的法律基础 1。纽约市市长佐赫兰·曼达尼批评谷歌利用其“垄断权力强迫将AI引入公立学校” 1。伊利诺伊州学区总监汉克·蒂勒认为此举损害了谷歌在教育领域建立的信任,并主张谷歌本应公开道歉,他说:“它可能已经对谷歌在教育领域建立的信任造成了很大伤害……谷歌本该直接说‘是我们的错’。” 1
此外,民间组织Common Sense Media将AI概览评级为“不可接受的风险” 1。北卡罗来纳州已有家长起诉谷歌,指控其Gemini聊天机器人在学校Chromebook上曾协助一名13岁女孩策划自杀和葬礼 1。
Google announced this month that schools will lose access to the entire Google Search tool if they require the removal of AI Overviews from the platform used by students 1. This decision has drawn sharp criticism from parents, educators, and politicians, including New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who accused the company of using "its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools" 1. Jodi Carreon highlighted the community's frustration, noting, "Parents are angry. They're very angry," while Common Sense Media rated AI Overviews as an "unacceptable risk" 1.
Former Google employee Tracy Pizzo theorized that this strategy may be linked to recent legal victories in antitrust lawsuits, where judges ruled that "Search and AI are an integrated product" 1. She argued that providing a specific opt-out switch for schools could serve as evidence that the two services are separable, potentially undermining Google’s legal standing 1. Meanwhile, Hank Thiele, a school district superintendent in Illinois, suggested the move damaged trust within the education sector, asserting that "It may have caused a lot of damage in the trust that Google has built in education... Google should have just plainly said, 'Our bad.'" 1. The controversy unfolds alongside other regulatory pressures, including a lawsuit in North Carolina where parents claim Gemini chatbot assistance on school Chromebooks helped a 13-year-old girl plan her suicide and funeral 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。