英国司法部正考虑调整《奥胡斯公约》框架下的法律保护措施,重点在于限制社区团体挑战威胁自然的规划决策时的诉讼费用上限 1。据环境律师透露,官员已私下会晤利益相关方,探讨取消或提高现行针对个人(5,000英镑)和组织(10,000英镑)败诉时支付对方费用的封顶保护 1。潜在的政策变动包括在每个挑战阶段将费用封顶加倍、移除法院认定“滥用司法审查”时的费用保护,以及允许众筹诉讼失败时承担高达募集金额70%的费用 1。
法律界人士对此表示强烈担忧,认为这些举措将严重阻碍环境正义并导致英国违反公约义务 1。Leigh Day律所高级环境律师 Carol Day 直言:“这些变化将使环境诉讼几乎停滞。” 1 ClientEarth UK负责人 Kyle Lischak 强调,挑战非法决定是人们制衡权力的少数方式之一,公众需要安全且负担得起的法庭途径来保护自己与自然 1。背景方面,《奥胡斯公约》于2005年被写入英国法律以保障参与环境事务民主过程的权利 1。斯塔默政府此前曾将自然视为增长障碍,并点名活动家 Dr Andrew Boswell 作为“Nimbys and zealots”的例子 1。值得注意的是,Boswell发起的反对A47扩张的法律战由2000人众筹73,000英镑资助,但最终败诉 1。
针对外界的质疑,政府发言人否认有取消对有理据索赔的费用保护计划,称政府致力于履行《奥胡斯公约》下的义务 1。
The UK government is considering measures that would weaken legal protections for environmental justice, specifically by removing or raising the caps on litigation costs for community groups challenging planning decisions. 1 According to environmental lawyers, the Ministry of Justice has held private meetings with stakeholders to discuss eliminating the current cost-capping protections, which limit liability for individuals who lose cases to £5,000 and for organizations to £10,000. 1 Proposed changes also include doubling these caps at each stage of a challenge and removing fee protection when courts deem judicial reviews "abusive." 1
A particularly controversial proposal suggests that groups relying on crowdfunding for legal challenges could be liable for up to 70% of the total funds raised if they lose their case. 1 Carol Day, a senior environmental lawyer at Leigh Day, stated that such changes would effectively bring environmental litigation to a standstill. 1 Kyle Lischak, head of ClientEarth UK, emphasized that the right to challenge illegal decisions is one of the few ways citizens can hold power accountable, arguing that people need safe and affordable access to courts to protect nature. 1 The Aarhus Convention, which was incorporated into UK law in 2005, guarantees rights regarding public participation in environmental decision-making. 1
Critics argue that the Starmer government views nature as an obstacle to growth, citing its previous characterization of activists like Dr. Andrew Boswell as "Nimbys and zealots." 1 Boswell’s failed legal campaign against the A47 expansion was funded by £73,000 from 2,000 crowd-funded supporters, illustrating the potential impact of the proposed cost liabilities on similar future actions. 1 In response, a government spokesperson denied plans to remove fee protections for meritorious claims, asserting that the administration remains committed to fulfilling its obligations under the Aarhus Convention. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。