针对谷歌副总裁Chris Phillips提出的“K-12学校必须接受其AI服务才能保留搜索引擎访问权”的要求,芝加哥公立学校(CPS)明确表态,宁愿寻找其他搜索解决方案也不愿被迫集成AI 1。CPS发言人透露,校方正在探索独立屏蔽AI Overviews的方法,若无法获得无AI版本的搜索服务,将着手更换搜索供应商 1。Phillips此前声称,由于Search与AI深度集成,这一要求是技术必然 1。
这一争议引发了包括剑桥和芝加哥在内的多地抗议活动,批评者指责谷歌的行为构成勒索 1。在芝加哥West Loop的谷歌办公室外,约30名由家长、教育工作者和学生组成的抗议者高呼“Hey Google, nice try. We don't want your Gemini.”以示反对 1。肯伍德学院高中学生Reese Mackey指出,AI仅仅是汇编随机来源产生无意义答案,无法提供真正的教学反馈 1。
除了直接对抗,美国多个主要学区已出台政策限制或禁止学生在教育场景中使用生成式AI 1。纽约市宣布将从2026-2027学年起,对学前班至八年级的学生端实施为期一年的生成式AI禁令 1。洛杉矶暂时封锁了所有年级学生设备上的生成式AI工具,而马里兰州弗雷德里克县校董会则以6比1的投票结果通过了限制幼儿园至12年级学生使用AI的决定 1。
Chicago Public Schools (CPS) has declared it would rather replace its search solution entirely than accept forced integration of artificial intelligence services. This stance follows a requirement from Google that K-12 institutions must adopt these AI features to retain student access to the company’s search engine 1. The dispute stems from claims by Google Vice President Chris Phillips, who argued that because Search is deeply integrated with AI, schools have no choice but to accept the company’s AI offerings to maintain their existing access 1. In response, a CPS spokesperson stated that the district is exploring methods to independently block "AI Overviews" and will seek alternative search solutions if a non-AI version cannot be provided 1.
The conflict has sparked protests in multiple cities, including Cambridge and Chicago, where critics have labeled Google’s requirements as extortionary 1. Approximately 30 demonstrators, comprising parents, educators, and students, gathered outside Google’s West Loop office in Chicago under the slogan, "Hey Google, nice try. We don't want your Gemini" 1. Reese Mackey, a student at Kenwood Academy High School, criticized the technology for merely compiling random sources into meaningless answers instead of providing genuine educational feedback 1.
This backlash coincides with broader restrictions on generative AI in other major school districts. New York City announced a one-year ban on student-facing generative AI for pre-K through eighth grade starting in the 2026–2027 academic year 1, while Los Angeles temporarily blocked such tools on student devices across all grades 1. Additionally, the Frederick County Board of Education in Maryland voted 6-1 to restrict AI use for students from kindergarten through 12th grade 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。