由记者朱莉娅·贝尔德及其儿子萨姆编辑、Fourth Estate出版的新书《成为男人》(Becoming a Man)收录了多位男性名人写给年轻男孩的建议信件 1。“男性圈”(manosphere)研究专家西蒙·科普兰在评论中指出,尽管书中部分建议具有价值,但其前提假设过于强调性别二元对立,即认为成为“好男人”与成为“好女人”所需的本质特质截然不同 1。科普兰认为,这种观点符合“男性圈”的二元论逻辑,可能无意中强化了隔离观念 1。
科普兰批评该书除引言外缺乏女性贡献者,主要由顺性别男性撰写,包括蒂姆·明钦、琼蒂·克莱波尔、理查德·托格内蒂、托尼·伯奇、休·范·凯伦堡、安德鲁·丹顿、卢克·贝特曼、阿马尔·辛格、达西·摩尔和罗布·米尔斯等人 1。他认为,这种仅针对男性的建议结构可能让读者产生“男孩不能向女性学习”的错误认知 1。相比之下,作者主张应更广泛地探讨作为“人”的共同特质,而非局限于性别角色 1。对此,书中贡献者卢克·贝特曼写道:“专注于身为男人的含义的危险在于,你会忘记你生来就是什么:人类。” 1 另一位贡献者阿马尔·辛格也表达类似观点:“首先,无论我们的性别或生活偏好如何,我们都必须是人。” 1 此外,评论还提及了斯蒂芬·格雷厄姆的著作《致我们儿子的信》,作为同类题材的另一参考 1。
Simon Copland, a self-identified expert on the manosphere, has published a review of the book Becoming a Man, edited by journalist Julia Baird and her son Sam Baird 1. Published by Fourth Estate, the volume features letters from various male celebrities addressed to young boys 1. While acknowledging the value of certain pieces of advice within the text, Copland argues that the book’s fundamental premise is problematic because it assumes that becoming a "good man" requires essentially different traits than becoming a "good woman," a view he contends aligns with the binary ideologies often found in manosphere communities 1.
A primary concern raised by the reviewer is the lack of female contributors beyond the introduction, noting that the content is predominantly written by cisgender men 1. Copland warns that this structure may inadvertently reinforce the isolationist notion that boys can only learn from other males, rather than recognizing shared human qualities 1. The list of contributors includes Tim Minchin, Jonty Claypole, Richard Tognetti, Tony Birch, Hugh van Cuylenburg, Andrew Denton, Luke Bateman, Amar Singh, Darcy Moore, and Rob Mills 1. Copland highlights direct quotes from two of these authors to support his critique: Luke Bateman states that focusing exclusively on what it means to be a man risks obscuring "the very thing that you were born to be: human," while Amar Singh emphasizes that "First of all, we have to be human beings, no matter what our sex or preferences are in life" 1. The review also references Stephen Graham’s work Letters To Our Sons as part of the broader context of such gendered guidance 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。