一项发表于2026年10月5日(周一)《生物学历史杂志》的新研究通过档案分析指出,罗莎琳德·富兰克林实际上早在詹姆斯·沃森和弗朗西斯·克里克之前就已认识到DNA的螺旋结构 1。该研究由费城科学历史研究所的Alistair Sponsel与伦敦国王学院的Brian Sutton共同完成,其核心发现挑战了长期以来认为富兰克林未能解读自身数据的传统观点 1。
研究证据显示,著名的“照片51号”并非随意拍摄的实验影像,而是基于同一天早些时候观察到的“照片49号”进行的特意优化与重新曝光的高分辨率图像,旨在用于发表,这证明富兰克林清楚该图像的重要性 1。尽管拥有确凿的数据认知,富兰克林在1952年2月的报告中却计划先解析数据更为丰富的脱水态A型结构,而非天然状态下的B型双螺旋结构 1。这一策略上的差异导致她错失了主导双螺旋发现的机会 1。
随后,莫里斯·威尔金斯将富兰克林的B型结构照片展示给沃森,促使后者与克里克构建了模型并因此荣获1962年诺贝尔医学奖 1。由于富兰克林于1958年因卵巢癌去世,年仅37岁,她在世时并未获得诺贝尔奖的表彰 1。
A new study published on Monday, October 5, 2026, in the Journal of the History of Biology challenges the prevailing view that Rosalind Franklin failed to interpret her own data regarding the structure of DNA 1. The research, led by Alistair Sponsel from the Institute for the History and Philosophy of Science and Technology in Philadelphia and Brian Sutton from King's College London, argues that Franklin recognized the helical nature of DNA prior to James Watson and Francis Crick 1. By analyzing archival materials, the authors contend that Franklin possessed a clear understanding of the molecule's structure, contradicting previous narratives that minimized her contribution 1.
The study focuses heavily on "Photograph 51," the iconic X-ray diffraction image taken by Franklin in May 1952, revealing that it was not a random experimental capture but a deliberately optimized high-resolution image intended for publication 1. Researchers found that this photograph was based on "Photograph 49," captured earlier the same day, indicating Franklin understood the significance of the visual evidence she generated 1. Additionally, an internal report from February 1952 shows Franklin planned to prioritize solving the structure of the "A-form" of DNA, which offered richer data, rather than the "B-form," which represents the natural double helix 1. This strategic decision meant she inadvertently delayed claiming dominance over the discovery of the double helix structure 1.
Historically, Maurice Wilkins showed Franklin's B-form photograph to James Watson, who subsequently collaborated with Francis Crick to build the famous model of DNA 1. Watson and Crick were awarded the Nobel Prize in Medicine in 1962 for this achievement 1. Franklin died of ovarian cancer in 1958 at the age of 37, precluding her from sharing in the Nobel recognition 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。