澳大利亚学者罗伯特·曼恩(Robert Manne)发表文章,反驳历史学家安德鲁·罗伯茨(Andrew Roberts)和西蒙·沙玛(Simon Schama)关于哈马斯袭击与以色列国防军在加沙行动道德对比的观点,指出以军造成大量平民死亡并存在种族灭绝意图 1。针对2023年10月7日哈马斯袭击导致约1,200名以色列人死亡的事件,罗伯茨在ABC电台节目中辩称哈马斯的暴行是“不可言说的道德犯罪”,而以军的杀戮则是“正义战争中难免发生的事情” 1。对此,曼恩引用《972 Magazine》的报道指出,以军使用名为“Lavender”的人工智能程序确定打击目标,允许根据哈马斯成员等级决定平民“附带损害”的数量,并称以军在加沙造成约75,000名巴勒斯坦人死亡,其中多数为无辜平民 1。
此外,曼恩批评了澳大利亚反犹主义特使吉莉安·西格尔(Jillian Segal)的报告,认为其建议全面采用国际大屠杀纪念联盟(IHRA)的定义,将针对以色列政策的合理批评标签化为反犹主义,从而压制言论自由 1。尽管西蒙·沙玛声称指控以色列犯下种族灭绝是当代反犹主义的表现,但曼恩反驳称沙玛对种族灭绝的法律定义理解有误 1。作为证明以色列政府存在种族灭绝意图的证据,曼恩列举了包括Yoav Gallant、Benjamin Netanyahu和Isaac Herzog在内的以色列高官言论,例如Gallant曾称巴勒斯坦人为“人类动物” 1。
Australian academic Robert Manne has published a rebuttal to arguments made by historians Andrew Roberts and Simon Schama, asserting that effectively addressing the rise in antisemitism requires confronting the truth regarding alleged war crimes committed during Israel’s military operations in Gaza 1. Manne challenges the moral equivalence drawn between Hamas and the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF), citing the October 7 Hamas attack which resulted in approximately 1,200 Israeli deaths, while contrasting this with what he describes as roughly 75,000 Palestinian fatalities in Gaza caused by IDF actions, most of whom were innocent civilians 1. He specifically critiques Lord Andrew Roberts’ defense on an ABC radio program, where Roberts characterized Hamas’ violence as an "unspeakable moral crime" while framing Israeli killings as unavoidable occurrences in a just war 1.
The article highlights allegations supported by reports from 972 Magazine, claiming the IDF utilized an artificial intelligence system named "Lavender" to determine targeting lists, which allegedly permitted varying levels of civilian collateral damage based on the hierarchical rank of Hamas members identified for elimination 1. Manne further disputes Sir Simon Schama’s assertion that accusing Israel of genocide constitutes modern antisemitism, arguing that Schama misunderstands the legal definition of the term 1. To support his claim of genocidal intent, the author points to statements made by senior Israeli officials, including Defense Minister Yoav Gallant’s description of Palestinians as "human animals," alongside comments attributed to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and President Isaac Herzog 1.
A central component of Manne’s argument focuses on the report by Australian Special Envoy for Fighting Antisemitism, Jillian Segal, who recommended the comprehensive adoption of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism 1. The author contends that this framework erroneously labels legitimate criticism of Israeli policy as antisemitic, thereby suppressing free speech within Australia 1. Manne characterizes Segal’s report as an assault on political discourse, arguing it unfairly categorizes left-wing progressive criticism of Israel as a manifestation of contemporary prejudice rather than valid political dissent 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。