澳大利亚媒体转型中心发布了一项关于澳大利亚主要媒体报道框架的研究,涵盖2023年至2026年间的以色列-加沙冲突以及2022年至2026年间的俄罗斯-乌克兰战争 1。该研究聚焦于《澳大利亚人报》(The Australian)、澳大利亚广播公司(ABC)、9News.com.au和卫报(The Guardian)四家媒体,旨在探讨新闻客观性与倡导式报道之间的张力 1。研究发现,在巴以冲突中,《澳大利亚人报》显著偏向以色列叙事,而其他媒体随事件发展调整了框架;在俄乌战争中,所有被调查媒体几乎完全采用西方和乌克兰视角 1。
在巴以冲突报道方面,整体样本中有49%的文章以以色列框架为主导,32%以巴勒斯坦框架为主导 1。其中,《澳大利亚人报》表现出明显的倾向性:71%的样本采用以色列框架,仅3%采用巴勒斯坦框架,且将亲巴勒斯坦倡导与反犹主义挂钩 1。相比之下,随着加沙死亡人数增加,其他三家媒体放大了巴勒斯坦的人道主义后果框架,ABC、9News和卫报的相关比例分别为38%、27%和54% 1。这表明媒体在巴以报道中的框架会随局势动态变化 1。
在俄罗斯-乌克兰战争的报道中,数据显示67%的样本连续以西方和乌克兰叙事为主导,0%的样本以俄罗斯框架为主导 1。俄方叙事未被作为主导框架引用,证实了俄乌报道中存在明显的叙事不对称 1。
A recent study by the Centre for Media Transition has revealed distinct narrative patterns in how major Australian news outlets covered two significant global conflicts. The research examined reporting from four key media organizations—The Australian, the ABC, 9News.com.au, and The Guardian—to explore the tension between journalistic objectivity and advocacy-driven coverage. 1
In its analysis of the Israel-Gaza conflict, which spanned coverage from 2023 to 2026, the study found that Israeli narratives dominated across all outlets, appearing as the primary framework in 49% of articles compared to 32% for Palestinian frameworks. 1 However, the degree of bias varied significantly among individual publishers; The Australian exhibited a pronounced preference for the Israeli perspective, with 71% of its sample adopting this frame while only 3% favored the Palestinian view, often linking pro-Palestinian advocacy directly to antisemitism. 1 Conversely, the ABC, 9News, and The Guardian adjusted their editorial focus as casualty figures in Gaza rose, amplifying humanitarian consequences associated with Palestinian suffering in 38%, 27%, and 54% of their respective samples. 1
The study’s findings regarding the Russia-Ukraine war, covered from 2022 to 2026, displayed a far more uniform alignment with Western perspectives. 1 Unlike the dynamic shifts observed in Middle East reporting, all investigated outlets consistently prioritized Western and Ukrainian narratives, which served as the dominant frame in 67% of the analyzed samples. 1 Notably, Russian viewpoints were never adopted as a leading framework, appearing in 0% of the cases studied. 1 These results highlight a stark asymmetry in narrative adoption during the Ukraine conflict compared to the more fluctuating and outlet-specific framing strategies employed during the Israel-Gaza crisis. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。