英国平等事务大臣布里吉特·菲利普森(Bridget Phillipson)近日公开指责保守党领袖凯米·巴德诺赫(Kemi Badenoch),称其在撤回对禁止转化疗法法案的支持后,表现出“没有兴趣支持LGBT+人群”的态度 1。这一争议源于保守党改变立场,不再支持一项旨在将试图改变某人性取向或性别身份的虐待行为定为犯罪的立法草案 1。根据该草案规定,此类违法行为最高可被判处五年监禁 1。
针对撤回支持的决定,巴德诺赫声称该法案范围过大,特别是涉及性别认同的部分可能导致父母因正常的养育方式而被捕 1。她引用了一个极端的假设案例,即如果父母拒绝让孩子自称“猫”,也可能面临法律风险 1。这一观点得到了智库Policy Exchange报告的支持,该报告指出法案对非二元性别身份的保护条款可能过于宽泛,甚至涵盖了如“catgender”(自我认同为猫)等情形 1。此外,保守党发言人还援引了凯拉·贝尔(Keira Bell)的案例,警告称该法案存在将年轻人在接受手术前进行的诚实、探索性对话定为犯罪的风险 1。对此,政府官员反驳称,法案设定了较高的定罪门槛,并不存在保守党所担忧的广泛误伤情况 1。
Equalities Minister Bridget Phillipson has accused Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch of having “no interest in supporting LGBT+ people” following the party’s withdrawal of support for the government’s planned ban on conversion practices 1. The draft legislation seeks to criminalize attempts to change an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity through abusive acts, proposing a maximum prison sentence of five years for such offenses 1.
Badenoch argues that the bill poses a threat to parental rights, claiming it could result in parents being arrested for how they raise their children 1. To illustrate her concerns, she cited a hypothetical scenario involving parents refusing to allow their child to identify as a cat 1. These fears are underpinned by a report from the think tank Policy Exchange, which suggests that protections regarding non-binary gender identities might be drafted too broadly, potentially encompassing self-identifications like “catgender” 1.
Conservative spokespersons have also referenced the case of Keira Bell when criticizing the bill, arguing that it risks criminalizing honest and exploratory conversations with young people prior to them undergoing surgery 1. In response to these objections, government officials have stated that the proposed law includes high thresholds to prevent the misuse of legislation against normal parenting behaviors 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。