基于音乐应用 Gitori 旗下“Find the Notes”游戏过去三年收集的数据,分析显示吉他指板上最难识别的音符主要集中在琴颈中上部。1 该数据集涵盖了超过一万名用户产生的 275,169 个数据点,其中红色高危区域位于 G 弦的第 6 至第 9 品,B 弦和 D 弦的第 7 至第 9 品紧随其后。1
在所有具体位置中,G 弦第 8 品的降 E 音(E♭)错误率最高,约有三分之一的回答者答错。1 相比之下,空弦和第 12 品最容易识别,其漏识率仅约为 6%,远低于第 8、9 品约 20% 的错误率;低音 E 弦和高音 E 弦边缘也是较易识别的区域。1
除了位置因素,音名本身的类型也影响识别难度。1 带有升号或降号的变化音比自然音更难识别且耗时更长,前者的错误率为 16%,平均耗时 2.5 秒,而后者错误率为 12%,平均耗时 2.2 秒。1 在具体音名中,F♯、B♭、A♭ 和 E♭ 被认为是最难识别的音符,而 E 音则是最容易的。1
An analysis of 275,169 data points collected from Gitori's "Find the Notes" game has identified specific regions on the guitar fretboard where players struggle most with note identification. The dataset, gathered from more than 10,000 users over a three-year period, indicates that the middle-upper section of the neck poses the greatest difficulty 1. Among individual positions, the E-flat note at the eighth fret of the G string recorded the highest error rate, with approximately one-third of respondents failing to identify it correctly 1.
The study highlights a distinct pattern in difficulty across different strings and frets. While the edges of the low E and high E strings are easiest to navigate, showing a miss rate of only about 6%, this rises to roughly 20% for notes around the eighth and ninth frets 1. Specifically, the sixth through ninth frets on the G string emerged as a critical high-error zone, followed closely by the seventh through ninth frets on the B and D strings 1. Conversely, open strings and the twelfth fret were found to be the easiest locations for players to identify accurately 1.
Beyond positional challenges, the type of note significantly impacts recognition speed and accuracy. Accidentals—notes marked with sharps or flats—are harder to recognize than natural notes, exhibiting an error rate of 16% compared to 12% for naturals 1. Players also took longer to identify accidentals, averaging 2.5 seconds versus 2.2 seconds for natural notes, representing an 11% increase in response time 1. The most difficult individual notes identified in the analysis were F-sharp, B-flat, A-flat, and E-flat, while E was determined to be the simplest note to recognize 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。