针对智能电视及流媒体设备的数据收集行为,The Verge等媒体向Amazon、Apple、Google、LG、Roku、Samsung、TCL、Hisense、Panasonic、Sony和Vizio共11家主要制造商提出了17个关于用户隐私的具体问题 1。调查核心聚焦于设备是否通过麦克风监听家庭声音、存储音频转录、使用自动内容识别(ACR)技术捕捉屏幕截图或音频指纹,以及传输位置信息等细节 1。此次行动揭示了各公司在默认设置、数据加密及用户退出机制上的巨大差异,部分公司详细说明了数据处理流程,而另一些则未予回应 1。
在收到回应的企业中,不同品牌采取了各异的技术策略以规避监视指控。Amazon Fire TV表示其麦克风仅在按下按钮或听到唤醒词时激活,不用于持续监听且无GPS硬件 1;Apple TV 4K称仅用于Siri唤醒词检测,不使用ACR,并通过Private Cloud Compute处理数据以保护隐私 1。Google TV指出若启用Assistant或Gemini,麦克风将处于待机状态,但语音和音频活动(VAA)默认关闭,若开启则存储在云端,且不使用ACR捕捉视频截图 1。LG电子声明语音识别默认关闭,需用户同意协议后才可开启,其ACR使用音频指纹而非截图,且默认关闭 1。Samsung强调不监听私人对话,不将语音录音存储在设备端,ACR功能也需用户主动启用 1。此外,Roku指出其电视无内置麦克风,遥控器需按住按钮使用,且美国的Smart TV Experience默认关闭 1;TCL则表示依赖第三方操作系统进行语音功能,不直接收集来自电视麦克风的音频数据 1。
然而,并非所有厂商都积极配合调查或提供透明信息。Vizio拒绝回答该调查问卷,Hisense在五次尝试后仍未回复邮件,Panasonic和Sony也未提供直接回答 1。除了透明度缺失,独立研究还发现了严重的合规问题。Northeastern University的一项研究发现,即便在用户选择退出后,Walmart旗下的Vizio智能电视仍继续发送数据,而Samsung和Roku的流量虽受限但未完全停止 1。此前,Vizio因隐私违规被罚款约2000万美元,但其“退出间谍”选项被指依然无效 2。目前,LG也因智能电视监视指控面临法律审查,多家科技媒体报道称这些品牌存在未经授权的数据收集行为并忽视用户的追踪退出请求 2。
A comprehensive investigation has sought detailed responses from eleven major smart television and streaming device manufacturers regarding their data collection methods, specifically focusing on microphone monitoring, screen capture technologies, and location tracking. The inquiry targeted companies including Amazon, Apple, Google, LG, Roku, Samsung, TCL, Hisense, Panasonic, Sony, and Vizio, asking 17 specific questions about whether devices listen to household conversations, store audio transcripts, use Automatic Content Recognition (ACR) to capture screenshots, or transmit IP and GPS location data by default 1. This effort comes amid broader reports that LG is facing legal scrutiny over smart TV spying allegations, while other brands have been accused of ignoring user privacy settings 2.
Several manufacturers provided specific details on how they handle user data and the extent of their surveillance capabilities. Amazon stated that its Fire TV microphones only activate when a button is pressed or a wake word is detected, confirming that no GPS hardware is present in the devices 1. Apple noted that the Apple TV 4K uses Siri for wake-word detection only, does not employ ACR technology, and processes data via Private Cloud Compute to enhance privacy protection 1. Regarding Google’s ecosystem, the company clarified that microphones remain on standby only if Assistant or Gemini is enabled, with Voice Activity Analysis (VAA) disabled by default; if enabled, audio is stored in the cloud, but the system does not use ACR to capture video screenshots 1.
In contrast, other companies outlined different approaches to voice recognition and content tracking. LG Electronics confirmed that voice recognition requires explicit user consent and is disabled by default, noting that any ACR implementation relies on audio fingerprints rather than visual screenshots and can be toggled off by users 1. Roku reported that its televisions lack built-in microphones, requiring users to hold a button on the remote for voice input, while the Smart TV Experience feature remains off by default in the United States 1. Samsung asserted that it does not monitor private conversations, stores no voice recordings locally, and keeps ACR functionality disabled unless actively enabled by the user 1. Meanwhile, TCL explained that voice features are managed by third-party operating systems, meaning the company does not directly collect audio data from TV microphones and that ACR control lies with the OS provider 1.
Despite these explanations, significant concerns remain regarding non-responsive manufacturers and past regulatory actions. Vizio declined to answer the survey questions entirely, a move that follows previous findings that its "opt out of espionage" setting was ineffective despite the company having been fined approximately $20 million for privacy violations 12. Similarly, Hisense did not respond after five attempts to contact them, and Panasonic and Sony also failed to provide direct answers to the core inquiries 1. Independent research from Northeastern University previously indicated that Walmart-owned Vizio devices continued sending data even after users selected opt-out options, with traffic from Samsung and Roku also continuing although at limited rates 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。