一项针对公共政策与慈善干预效果的论述指出,旨在改善社会的各类举措往往缺乏实际成效,决策者常因高估自身意图的影响力而忽视对结果的严格验证 1。文章援引多项案例佐证这一观点:2009年美国国会投入30亿美元用于“学校改进补助金”,结果显示该项目无明显效果;秘鲁一项为期10年的随机对照试验(RCT)显示,“一个儿童一台笔记本电脑”计划对学业成绩零影响;此外,无条件现金转移支付的大型随机对照研究发现,其对幸福感的提升效果微弱,甚至可能产生负面心理影响 1。
在社会治理与慈善领域,缺乏明确目标或数据支撑的项目同样面临困境。美国政府曾花费2.8亿美元帮助阿富汗女性就业,但无法确认是否有女性获得工作;国土安全部(DHS)被指未设定明确目标或收集数据以评估禁毒行动的有效性 1。即便是在资源高度集中的教育捐赠中,肯尼斯·兰戈尼向纽约大学医学院捐赠1亿美元免除学费,虽使申请量增加47%,但未改变学生生源结构或专业选择倾向 1。
这种普遍存在的无效性与社会学家Peter Rossi在1987年提出的“评估铁律”相呼应,该理论认为大型社会项目的净预期影响为零 1。尽管心理学中著名的“控制错觉”经典研究常被引用以解释人们为何倾向于相信自身行为能产生结果,但该研究的原始实验使用的是橄榄球卡片而非彩票,参与者只是选择了自己喜爱的球员,且后续严格复现未发现显著差异 1。作者最终呼吁,在推行新政策前,应进行更谦卑的实验性检查,以替代基于过度自信的盲目干预 1。
A recent analysis argues that most public policies and charitable interventions aimed at improving society are ineffective, often failing to achieve their intended outcomes despite substantial funding. The piece highlights several high-profile examples of such failures, including a 2009 congressional allocation of $3 billion for the "School Improvement Grants," which showed no discernible impact 1. Similarly, the U.S. government spent $280 million to help Afghan women find employment, yet it remains unclear whether any women actually secured jobs as a result 1. Another significant failure involves Kenneth Langone’s $100 million donation to New York University School of Medicine to eliminate tuition fees; while applications increased by 47%, the intervention did not alter the student demographic profile or career preferences 1.
The critique extends beyond specific programs to broader psychological and methodological issues. Sociologist Peter Rossi proposed the "Iron Law of Evaluation" in 1987, asserting that the net expected impact of large social projects is zero 1. This perspective is reinforced by evidence from rigorous testing: a decade-long randomized controlled trial (RCT) in Peru regarding the "One Laptop Per Child" program found zero effect on academic performance 1, and large-scale RCTs on unconditional cash transfers revealed only weak improvements in well-being, with some studies suggesting potential negative psychological effects 1. Furthermore, the Department of Homeland Security has been criticized for failing to set clear goals or collect data to assess the effectiveness of its drug interdiction efforts 1.
The Illusion of Control and the Need for Humble Experimentation
The author attributes this widespread ineffectiveness partly to the "illusion of control," a psychological phenomenon where individuals overestimate their influence over events. While referencing a classic 1975 study on this concept, the article notes that recent re-evaluations have complicated the narrative; the original experiment used football cards rather than lottery tickets, and strict replications have failed to find significant differences in perceived control based on choice alone 1. Nevertheless, the core argument persists: decision-makers often ignore the necessity of verifying results due to an overconfidence in their own intentions.
Consequently, the article calls for a shift toward more humble, experimental approaches before implementing new policies. Rather than relying on blind confidence in good intentions, proponents of social change should prioritize rigorous evaluation and pilot programs. This approach aims to address the gap between the massive resources invested in social initiatives and the often negligible returns observed in reality 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。