河南广播电视台《小莉帮忙》栏目于2024年11月10日发表报道,揭露了上门家电维修行业在简单故障处理中存在的虚假报价和过度收费现象 1。调查记者设置了“电池没电”和“自闭阀未开”两种简单故障场景,并下单邀请了5位维修师傅上门服务 1。结果显示,来自啄木鸟、天鹅到家及58到家的3位师傅存在不良行为,而另外2位师傅则如实告知仅需收取30元上门费或指出无需维修 1。
在具体违规案例中,一名啄木鸟平台的师傅在更换电池后谎称设备存在“总成故障”,向用户收取了260元费用 1。一名天鹅到家平台的师傅谎报“总成坏了”,实际仅拨开阀门便收费244元 1。此外,一名58到家平台的师傅声称设备“脉冲坏了”,收费160元 1。
此前,央视315晚会曾曝光啄木鸟家庭维修存在“小病大修”问题 1。针对这一情况,啄木鸟随后发布了整改方案 1。该方案要求实现维修过程透明化,包括全过程拍照录像以及实时同步记录 1。同时,公司规定对于非机器故障的服务,只收取上门费与检测费,以规范收费标准 1。
An investigation conducted on November 10, 2024, by the Henan Broadcasting and Television Station’s "Xiao Li Helps" segment exposed irregularities in home appliance repair services involving platforms such as Woodpecker Family Repair, Swan to Home, and 58 to Home 1. Reporters simulated two simple faults—a dead battery and an unopened valve—and summoned five technicians 1. The results showed that three of these professionals engaged in fraudulent pricing or excessive charging, while only two provided honest assessments 1.
The misconduct involved inflating simple fixes into major component replacements. A technician from Woodpecker Family Repair charged 260 yuan by falsely claiming a "assembly failure" after simply replacing a battery 1. Similarly, a worker from Swan to Home collected 244 yuan by lying about a broken assembly when merely opening a valve was required 1, and a representative from 58 to Home demanded 160 yuan for a non-existent "pulse ignition fault" 1. In contrast, the remaining two technicians transparently disclosed that no repairs were needed or limited their charges to a standard 30-yuan service call fee 1.
This report follows previous scrutiny of the industry, notably highlighting that CCTV's 315 Gala had earlier exposed Woodpecker Family Repair for recommending unnecessary major repairs for minor faults 1. In response to past criticism, the company announced rectification measures aimed at increasing transparency, which include mandatory photo and video documentation of the entire repair process, real-time synchronization of records, and strict limits on fees for services unrelated to actual machine malfunctions, allowing only service call and inspection fees 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。