澳大利亚高等法院在“农场透明度国际组织”(Farm Transparency International)与 Game Meats Company 的诉讼中作出裁决,认定屠宰场不能通过版权法控制由活动人士非法闯入拍摄的虐待动物视频 1。尽管法院命令活动人士销毁其持有的视频副本,但驳回了屠宰场获得视频版权的请求,以保护公众言论自由和媒体权利 1。这一判决对吹哨人、新闻自由及动物福利监管具有深远影响 1。
事件背景为2024年,活动人士七次非法闯入维多利亚州一家屠宰场,安装并拍摄隐藏摄像头视频 1。视频内容显示山羊在未完全昏迷情况下被割喉,以及幼年山羊在受惊状态下的痛苦叫声 1。在初审阶段,联邦法院一审判决 Game Meats 因非法侵入获赔13万美元($130,000 AUD),但未涉及其他赔偿 1。随后,联邦法院全席法庭曾裁定 Game Meats 通过“推定信托”(constructive trust)拥有视频版权 1。
澳大利亚高等法院拒绝授予屠宰场版权,认为这会侵犯未参与非法入侵者的言论自由;但命令活动人士删除视频副本 1。此外,Channel Seven 电视台未被禁止发布该视频,新闻自由得到保护 1。
The High Court of Australia has ruled that a slaughterhouse cannot use copyright law to control footage of animal abuse obtained through illegal trespass, a decision with significant implications for whistleblowers, press freedom, and animal welfare oversight 1. In the case involving Farm Transparency International and Game Meats Company, the court rejected the company’s request to claim ownership of videos secretly recorded during seven unlawful entries into a Victorian abattoir in 2024 1. While the judges ordered the activists to destroy their copies of the footage, they determined that granting copyright to the abattoir would infringe upon the free speech rights of individuals who were not involved in the trespass 1.
The disputed videos depicted goats being slaughtered while not fully unconscious and showed young kids emitting distress calls while frightened 1. Prior to this final ruling, the Full Federal Court had established that Game Meats owned the video copyright via a "constructive trust," but the High Court overturned this aspect regarding ownership rights 1. Although the initial Federal Court judgment awarded Game Meats AUD 130,000 in damages specifically for the act of trespass, no further compensation was granted for other claims 1. The High Court’s stance ensures that Channel Seven is not prohibited from publishing the material, thereby safeguarding media rights to report on such issues 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。