布鲁斯·帕斯科(Bruce Pascoe)出版了新书《欧洲心智:殖民主义、资本主义、基督教以及如何恢复》(The European Mind: Colonialism, Capitalism, Christianity and how to recover),该书由Magabala Books发行 1。书中延续了其前作《黑暗鸸鹋》的观点,批判由“欧洲心智”主导的工业化农业、资本主义及基督教对自然造成的破坏,并主张通过重新评估原住民的土地管理方式来“去殖民化”思维以拯救地球 1。帕斯科的核心论点认为,“欧洲心智”阻碍了必要的变革,犁耕并非农业生产所必需,且殖民主义将土地绑定于全球资本主义体系之中 1。
来自澳大利亚对话网(The Conversation Australia)的书评作者蒂姆·罗尔斯(Tim Rowse)指出,这本书本质上是一本高度道德化和政治化的历史著作,而非纯粹的学术智力史或考古学作品 1。罗尔斯批评该书虽然敢于挑战既有观念,但道德说教的色彩浓厚而缺乏细微差别 1。此外,评论者还质疑帕斯科在选择性引用考古学证据时表现出反智倾向和自相矛盾,特别是书中引用了Paulette Steeves关于西半球人类居住时间可追溯至10万年的理论,以及维多利亚州Point Ritchie遗址可能显示12万年前人类存在的证据,尽管这些观点在考古学界极具争议 1。
Bruce Pascoe’s new book, The European Mind: Colonialism, Capitalism, Christianity and how to recover, published by Magabala Books, argues that a dominant "European mind" obstructs necessary societal change 1. The work advocates for decolonising thought through the reassessment of Indigenous land management practices 1. It critiques industrial agriculture, capitalism, and Christianity as forces responsible for environmental destruction, positing that ploughing is not essential for food production and that colonialism has tethered land to global economic systems 1.
In a review for The Conversation Australia, Tim Rowse characterises the book as a highly moralised and political history rather than a neutral intellectual or archaeological study 1. Rowse highlights Pascoe’s reliance on controversial archaeological theories, specifically Paulette Steeves’ proposal that human habitation in the Western Hemisphere dates back 100,000 years, and evidence from Victoria’s Point Ritchie site suggesting human presence 120,000 years ago 1. The reviewer criticises this selective citation of disputed evidence as an anti-intellectual tendency that introduces internal contradictions into the book’s argument 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。