英国法官本纳森(Mr Justice Bennathan)在宣判喜剧演员拉塞尔·布兰德(Russell Brand)时,因明确驳斥“强奸迷思”并谴责旁观者纵容行为而受到广泛赞誉 1。该判决认定布兰德犯有强奸一名女性及性侵犯另外三人的罪名,判处其10年半监禁 1。
在量刑陈述中,本纳森法官强调,无论女性穿着、地点或饮酒情况如何,她们均拥有拒绝和寻求正义的权利 1。法官特别指出:“无论女性穿什么、去哪里,甚至喝什么,当像你这样的性掠食者未经同意行事时,她们保留说‘不’并要求司法公正的权利。”1 这一表态直接纠正了庭审中出现的受害者有罪论调,并对公众讨论产生积极影响 1。
多位重要人物对法官的裁决给予高度评价 1。刑事辩护律师协会主席安德鲁·托马斯KC、副主席卡玛·梅利KC,以及英格兰和威尔士强奸危机组织首席执行官西娅·伯格曼均表达了支持态度 1。此外,“结束针对女性暴力联盟”副主任丹尼斯·乌古尔与工党副领袖露西·鲍威尔也称赞了这一判决的社会意义 1。
Mr Justice Bennathan has received widespread commendation for his approach to sentencing comedian Russell Brand, who was handed a prison term of 10 and a half years for raping one woman and sexually assaulting three others 1. In his remarks, the judge explicitly challenged bystander complicity and corrected victim-blaming narratives that emerged during the trial 1. This judicial stance has been praised by legal experts, advocacy groups, and politicians for its positive impact on public discourse regarding sexual violence 1.
The sentencing remarks featured a direct rebuke of common misconceptions surrounding consent. Mr Justice Bennathan stated, "Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Russell Brand, act without their consent" 1. By articulating this principle clearly within the context of the verdict, the judge addressed issues raised by organizations such as Rape Crisis England & Wales and the End Violence Against Women Coalition 1. Leaders including Ciara Bergman, CEO of Rape Crisis England & Wales, and Deniz Uğur, Deputy Director of the End Violence Against Women Coalition, joined figures like Andrew Thomas KC, President of the Criminal Bar Association, Kama Melly KC, Vice-President of the Criminal Bar Association, and Lucy Powell, Labour Party Deputy Leader, in highlighting the importance of dispelling rape myths in court proceedings 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。