伦敦枢密院司法委员会(JCPC)作为特立尼达和多巴哥的最高上诉法院,裁定该国将同性亲密行为定为犯罪的法律违反了“尊重私人及家庭生活的基本个人权利”1。这是JCPC历史上首次受理并裁决关于同性亲密行为去罪化的案件1。原告为62岁的双重国籍人士Jason Jones,他经过长达11年的法律诉讼最终胜诉1。此前,特立尼达和多巴哥政府曾于2018年推翻高等法院的有利判决,此次终审判决被视为加勒比地区乃至英联邦范围内同性恋权利斗争的重要里程碑1。
在宣判时,Lord Sales指出,这些法律“不能被视为在一个适当尊重个人权利和自由的社会中合理正当”1。特立尼达和多巴哥总检察长辩称法律受“保留条款”保护,但JCPC一致支持Jones,认为1986年加重惩罚的法律修改使保留条款不再适用1。判决前,特立尼达和多巴哥是约34个仍基于殖民时期英国法律将同性恋定罪的前英联邦国家之一1。
律师Anand Ramlogan SC称这是“特立尼达和多巴哥同性恋权利、平等尊严以及尊重私人及家庭生活的标志性胜利”1。原告Jason Jones表示希望此判决能“加速争取完全平等的斗争”,并称:“今天这个信息结束了。”1
The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) in London has struck down laws in Trinidad and Tobago that criminalized same-sex intimate acts, ruling that they violate fundamental personal rights to respect for private and family life 1. This decision marks the end of an 11-year legal battle led by Jason Jones, a dual-national activist who stated that the verdict "ends this message" sent by these discriminatory laws 1. As the highest court of appeal for the Caribbean nation, the JCPC delivered its first-ever ruling on the decriminalization of consensual same-sex intimacy 1. Prior to this overturn, Trinidad and Tobago was one of approximately 34 former British colonies where colonial-era legislation still criminalized homosexuality 1.
Jones, aged 62, expressed hope that this judgment would accelerate the struggle for full equality 1. The government of Trinidad and Tobago had previously argued that the statutes were protected under "savings clauses," but the panel unanimously sided with Jones, determining that a 1986 amendment increasing penalties rendered such protections invalid 1. Lord Sales, delivering the opinion, asserted that the laws could not be considered reasonably justifiable in a society that properly respects individual rights and freedoms 1. Legal representative Anand Ramlogan SC described the outcome as a landmark victory for gay rights, equal dignity, and respect for private and family life in the country 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。