北京二中院审理一起直播购买翡翠纠纷案。消费者王某在直播间以8030元购得两只手镯,经鉴定均非天然A货翡翠。 1 其中一只为经过染色和充填处理的石英岩玉,另一只为经过染色、漂白及充填处理的翡翠。 1 交易过程中,商家引导王某脱离平台监管,通过微信沟通并分别向个人支付宝账户转账3850元和4180元。 1
针对王某提出的撤销合同、退还货款8030元、三倍赔偿24090元及检测费560元的诉讼请求,法院最终支持了退还货款及支付检测费的诉求,但驳回了三倍赔偿请求。 1 法官指出,因证据不足,不支持欺诈认定,故驳回惩罚性赔偿;但鉴于其中一只手镯材质与约定不符,商家行为构成违约。 1 办案法官提醒消费者警惕私下交易风险及低价陷阱,建议通过正规渠道购买并妥善保留相关证据,以避免维权困难。 1
The Second Intermediate People's Court of Beijing has ruled in a dispute involving jade bracelets purchased via a live-streaming platform, ordering the merchant to refund 8,030 yuan and pay 560 yuan for inspection fees 1. The plaintiff, identified as Wang, had transferred two amounts totaling 8,030 yuan, specifically 3,850 yuan and 4,180 yuan, to purchase the items 1. Subsequent appraisal revealed that neither bracelet was natural Grade A jadeite 1. One item was determined to be quartzite jade that had undergone dyeing and filling treatments, while the other was jadeite that had been dyed, bleached, and filled 1.
In its judgment, the court rejected Wang’s request to revoke the contract and claim triple compensation totaling 24,090 yuan, citing insufficient evidence to prove fraud by the merchant 1. Nevertheless, the court found that the material composition of one bracelet did not match the agreed-upon terms, constituting a breach of contract, which justified the order for a full refund of the purchase price and the associated testing costs 1. The case highlights significant risks associated with transactions conducted outside official platforms; the merchant had guided Wang to communicate via WeChat and transfer funds through personal Alipay accounts, which complicated her ability to seek redress 1.
Following the ruling, judges issued a warning to consumers regarding the pitfalls of private transactions and abnormally low prices in live-streaming commerce 1. They advised buyers to strictly use official channels provided by platforms and to meticulously preserve all transaction records and communication logs to protect their legal rights in the event of disputes 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。