2026年9月24日,内蒙古锡林浩特市人民法院对“学力星球”App涉嫌组织、领导传销活动罪一案作出终审无罪判决 1。创始人任博等5名被告人在被羁押1329天后当庭释放 1。公诉机关未在法定抗诉期内提起抗诉,该判决随即生效 1。
法院审理认定,“学力星球”平台提供真实的视频阅读服务,其收入来源呈现多样化特征,并非单纯依靠发展人员数量骗取财物,因此认为公诉机关指控的证据不足 1。在辩护环节中,辩方强调平台拥有369本书籍资源及每月超过40万元的真实运营成本,且会员具备退费机制,收入并不单一依赖新会员缴纳的费用 1。据统计,涉案平台注册用户达170余万人,付费会员逾18万,累计收取充值费近四千万元,广告费一千两百余万元,涉及层级多达38级 1。
中国政法大学教授印波将此案定性为“罕见的无罪判决”,并指出当前存在“以刑代行”以及行政违法与刑事犯罪界限模糊的问题 1。中央财经大学教授郭华亦表示,需要重新界定传销行为的范围 1。尽管刑事层面获得无罪判决,多位专家提醒该商业模式是否构成行政违法仍有待市场监管部门进一步认定 1。截至发稿时,“学力星球”方面暂未收到行政处罚通知 1。被告人任博计划申请国家赔偿,并在考虑重启项目的同时放弃原有的推广模式 1。
On September 24, 2026, the Xilinhot People's Court in Inner Mongolia issued a final acquittal for Ren Bo, founder of the "Xuelixingqiu" app, and four other defendants who had been charged with organizing and leading pyramid scheme activities 1. The court ruled that the prosecution lacked sufficient evidence to prove the platform engaged in criminal conduct, noting that "Xuelixingqiu" provided genuine video reading services with diverse income sources rather than relying solely on recruiting members to defraud property 1. Following the verdict, all five defendants were released from custody after being detained for 1,329 days 1. Since the prosecutorial authority did not file an appeal within the designated period, the judgment has become legally effective 1.
The case involved significant user engagement and financial flows, with over 1.7 million registered users, more than 180,000 paid members, nearly 40 million yuan in membership fees, over 12 million yuan in advertising revenue, and a distribution hierarchy reaching 38 levels 1. However, the defense successfully argued that the platform maintained 369 books, incurred substantial monthly operational costs exceeding 400,000 yuan, offered refundable memberships, and did not derive its income exclusively from new member contributions 1. This outcome has sparked debate among legal experts regarding the boundaries between administrative violations and criminal offenses in digital business models; Professor Yin Bo from China University of Political Science and Law described it as a "rare acquittal" that highlights issues of using criminal law to substitute for administrative enforcement, while Professor Guo Hua from Central University of Finance and Economics suggested a need to redefine the scope of pyramid schemes 1. As of the report, the "Xuelixingqiu" project had not received any notice of administrative penalty from market supervision authorities 1. Ren Bo plans to apply for state compensation and is considering relaunching the project, though he intends to abandon the original promotion model 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。