马萨诸塞州普利茅斯法官威廉·沙利文于周一驳回了被告林赛·克兰西辩护团队提出的撤销谋杀指控请求,裁定对其重新审判不构成违宪的双重危险 12。这一裁决为检方就克兰西涉嫌于2023年杀害其三名年幼子女的指控推进第二次审判扫清了法律障碍 12。
案件源于2023年1月24日发生在马萨诸塞州德克斯伯里的惨剧,检方指控克兰西故意勒死其5岁女儿Cora、3岁儿子Dawson以及8个月大的儿子Callan 2。在首次审判中,陪审团陷入僵局:11名陪审员倾向于以精神错乱为由宣判无罪,仅有一名陪审员坚持认定一级谋杀罪名成立,导致法官于9月4日宣布审判无效 12。辩护团队曾主张法官过早宣布审判无效且应排除持异议的陪审员,但沙利文法官认为基于陪审团僵局的宣告无效具有“明显必要性” 2。此外,法官还驳回了辩方查阅该唯一持异议陪审员记录及传唤其作证的请求,称此举将构成“不当胁迫” 2。目前,克兰西被关押在马萨诸塞州一家州立精神病医院和医疗设施内,法院定于11月16日讨论第二次审判的具体日程,此前法官建议审判可能在次年3月开始 2。
A Massachusetts judge has ruled that retrying Lindsay Clancy for the murder of her three young children does not violate constitutional protections against double jeopardy, effectively clearing the legal path for a second trial. 12 On Monday, Judge William Sullivan in Plymouth denied a motion by defense attorneys to dismiss the case, determining that the mistrial declared previously was justified by "manifest necessity" due to jury deadlock. 12 The decision overturns the defense's argument that the original proceedings should end permanently because the jury could not reach a unanimous verdict regarding Clancy’s guilt or insanity. 12
The core of the prosecution’s case centers on allegations that Clancy intentionally strangled her five-year-old daughter Cora, three-year-old son Dawson, and eight-month-old son Callan at their home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, on January 24, 2023. 2 During the initial trial, which ended in a mistrial on September 4 after a holdout juror prevented consensus, eleven jurors leaned toward acquitting Clancy based on mental illness, while one insisted on a first-degree murder conviction. 12 Judge Sullivan also rejected requests from the defense to access records of the dissenting juror or to call them as a witness, stating that such actions would constitute improper coercion. 2 Following this ruling, the court is scheduled to discuss the timeline for the retrial on November 16, with the judge suggesting proceedings could potentially begin in March of the following year. 2 Clancy remains detained in a state psychiatric facility and medical institution in Massachusetts while awaiting further legal developments. 2
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。