西澳大利亚警方近期完成了一项为期五个月的实时面部识别技术试点项目。在试点期间,警方共进行了100次部署,覆盖43个地点,累计扫描了1,380,882张人脸 1。该项目最终导致122人被捕,同时产生了9次错误警报 1。此外,试点期间警方还接触了146名注册性犯罪者,并定位了10人进行福利检查 1。
在具体的重大活动保障中,仅珀斯皇家展览期间就扫描了223,749张人脸,由此引发了15次警报,促成3次逮捕,并使警方与7名注册性犯罪者取得了接触 1。尽管试点已于周六结束,且相关监控车辆已从公共部署中撤除,但围绕该技术的争议仍在持续 1。西澳警察局长Col Blanch表示:“没有人因此被捕。没有人提出投诉。” 1 警方目前正在进行内部评估,以审查技术表现及社区影响 1。
然而,Civil Liberties Australia首席执行官Bill Rowlings对警方的说法提出批评。他质疑警方关于错误率的计算方式,指出如果按照定罪率来计算,“错误”率可能高达50%,而警方宣称的0.00065%的低错误率具有误导性 1。Rowlings还强调,该技术在未获合理怀疑的情况下大规模收集数据存在隐私风险 1。
Western Australian police have concluded a five-month trial of real-time facial recognition technology, during which they scanned more than 1.38 million faces across 43 locations in 100 deployments 1. The initiative resulted in the arrest of 122 individuals and generated nine false alerts 1. Beyond law enforcement actions, the system identified 146 registered sex offenders and located 10 people for welfare checks 1. A significant portion of the scanning occurred during the Royal Perth Show, where 223,749 faces were processed, leading to 15 alerts, three arrests, and seven interactions with registered sex offenders 1.
Police officials defended the technology's performance, citing an error rate of just 0.00065% 1. WA Police Commissioner Col Blanch stated that no one was arrested based on these false positives and noted that there had been no complaints regarding the incidents 1. However, civil liberties advocates challenged this assessment, arguing that the method used to calculate errors is misleading 1. Bill Rowlings, CEO of Civil Liberties Australia, contended that if measured by conviction rates, the "error" rate could be as high as 50% 1. Critics also raised concerns about privacy risks associated with mass data collection without reasonable suspicion 1.
The monitoring vehicles involved in the trial have been withdrawn from public deployment following its conclusion on Saturday 1. Police are currently conducting an internal review to assess the technology’s overall performance and its impact on the community 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。