澳大利亚参议员宝琳·汉森(Pauline Hanson)成功说服高等法院受理其上诉,挑战此前因违反《种族歧视法》第18C条而作出的司法裁决 1。该案已进入终审阶段,高等法院的听证会很可能在明年年初举行 1。此前,联邦法院一审及全席法庭均裁定汉森的行为违法,并下令删除推文、支付诉讼费 1。
案件起因于2022年9月,绿党参议员米雷恩·法鲁基(Mehreen Faruqi)就伊丽莎白二世女王去世发表批评殖民历史的言论 1。法鲁基称:“我无法哀悼一个建立在被殖民者生命、土地和财富之上的种族主义帝国的领导人” 1。对此,汉森回复称:“显然你不开心,那就收拾行李滚回巴基斯坦去” 1。正是这条侮辱性回复导致了后续的法律纠纷 1。
此次上诉的核心焦点在于《种族歧视法》第18C条的合宪性问题 1。高等法院将重点审查两个方面:首先,联邦政府是否有权依据包括《公民权利和政治权利国际公约》或《消除一切形式种族歧视国际公约》在内的条约义务,制定涵盖“冒犯”和“侮辱”内容的第18C条;其次,该条款是否侵犯了澳大利亚宪法中隐含的政治交流自由 1。由于涉及对言论限制法律的根本性审查,该案的判决结果预计将对澳大利亚其他限制言论的法律产生广泛影响 1。
Australian Senator Pauline Hanson has successfully persuaded the High Court of Australia to hear her appeal against a ruling that she breached Section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 1. The legal dispute stems from an exchange in September 2022, triggered by Green Party Senator Mehreen Faruqi’s comments regarding the death of Queen Elizabeth II and colonial history 1. In response to Faruqi’s statement, "I cannot mourn the leader of a racist empire built on stolen lives, land and wealth of colonised people," Hanson replied, "It’s clear you’re not happy, so pack your bags and piss off back to Pakistan" 1.
The Federal Court and its Full Bench previously ruled that Hanson’s conduct was unlawful, ordering her to delete the tweet and pay litigation costs 1. The High Court will now determine whether the federal government has the constitutional power to enact Section 18C based on treaty obligations, such as those under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights or the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination 1. Additionally, the court will assess if the provision, which covers being "offensive" and "insulting," infringes upon the implied freedom of political communication protected by the Australian Constitution 1. Hearings are expected to take place early next year, with the judgment likely to have broad implications for other laws restricting speech in Australia 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。