2024年6月28日,游客刘先生自驾前往西藏日喀则定日县珠峰大本营时,在距目的地20多公里的S515省道遭遇景区工作人员设卡拦截。1 景区方面要求游客不得直接驾车进入,必须花费120元购买接驳车票换乘观光车方可抵达。1 尽管刘先生签署自驾免责协议后试图继续行驶,但在海拔4800米处再次被景区车辆逼停,经报警调解后,直至次日才由景区人员跟车放行。1
针对此事引发的路权争议,刘先生于2024年8月正式向法院提起诉讼,索赔320元。1 定日县文旅局和珠峰边境派出所已于9月1日对该案件予以行政立案。1 记者调查获悉,自2023年8月23日起,珠峰景区已取消车辆环保费,规定除特种车辆外,其余车辆乘客均需统一换乘景区旅游观光车。1
对于景区在S515省道这一公共道路上设卡强制换乘的合法性,各方存在不同解读。1 西藏自治区交通运输厅表示,一般而言景区在省道设卡行为不合规,但关于是否单独报批的情况尚不清楚。1 北京市中闻律师事务所律师刘凯指出,关键在于景区是否有权在省道设卡限制通行并强制收费,若确属公共道路,其通行秩序应优先于景区经营管理权。1 当地文旅部门回应称,部分路段性质划分存在争议,目前正由交通厅推进明确。1
A self-driving tourist has filed a lawsuit against the Mount Everest scenic area, alleging that its enforcement of mandatory shuttle bus transfers on a public provincial road constitutes an infringement of his right to travel freely. The dispute arose on June 28, 2024, when the tourist, identified as Mr. Liu, was intercepted by scenic area staff at a checkpoint on the S515 Provincial Highway, located more than 20 kilometers from the base camp 1. Authorities required him to cease driving his own vehicle and purchase a shuttle ticket for 120 yuan to reach the destination 1. Although Mr. Liu signed a liability waiver to continue his journey, he was forced to stop again by scenic area vehicles at an elevation of 4,800 meters; after police mediated the confrontation, he was permitted to proceed only under escort by scenic area personnel the following day 1.
In response to the incident, Mr. Liu formally sued the scenic area in August, seeking compensation of 320 yuan, while the Dingri County Culture and Tourism Bureau and the Everest Border Police Station administratively registered the case on September 1 1. The core of the legal controversy lies in the regulatory status of the S515 road. The Tibet Autonomous Region Department of Transport confirmed that generally, setting up checkpoints on provincial highways is non-compliant, though it remained unclear whether this specific installation had received separate approval 1. Since August 23, 2023, the scenic area has enforced a policy requiring all passengers, except those in special-purpose vehicles, to transfer to official tourism shuttles after abolishing the environmental fee for private cars 1. Local culture and tourism officials stated that there is a dispute regarding the classification of certain road sections, with the transport department working to clarify the matter 1. Legal expert Liu Kai from Beijing Zhongwen Law Firm argued that if the route is indeed a public road, the scenic area lacks the authority to restrict passage or impose compulsory charges, emphasizing that the order of public traffic takes precedence over scenic area management rights 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。