一位拥有20年编程经验的匿名资深软件工程师发布博客文章,阐述了其对使用人工智能(作者戏称为“clankers”)编写代码的看法 1。该工程师主张,尽管AI能够快速生成高质量代码,但人类开发者仍必须亲自阅读和审查这些代码,不能盲目信任AI的输出 1。文章强调,只要开发者的名字出现在Pull Request上并负责运维,就必须对代码质量负全责;作者认为工程自豪感源于对代码质量的掌控,拒绝将责任推卸给工具 1。
在分析当前AI技术的局限性时,该作者指出AI缺乏真正的学习能力和好奇心,受限于上下文窗口 1。此外,AI倾向于通过不断添加代码来解决问题,而非进行重构或优化,这容易引入累积性错误,甚至生成冗余或错误的单元测试 1。作者认为,目前业界尚不存在能够保证AI输出质量的标准化流程或可重复的控制机制 1。
A senior software engineer with 20 years of experience has published a blog post arguing that developers must personally read and review code generated by artificial intelligence. 1 The author, who refers to AI tools as "clankers," contends that despite the speed and apparent quality of AI-generated code, human oversight remains essential because current systems lack true learning capabilities and curiosity, and are prone to introducing cumulative errors. 1
The article emphasizes that accountability cannot be delegated to tools; if a developer’s name appears on a Pull Request or they are responsible for operations via on-call rotations, they bear full responsibility for the code's integrity. 1 The writer asserts that engineering pride stems from direct control over code quality, rejecting the notion of blindly trusting AI outputs. 1
According to the author, current AI coding assistants often solve problems by continuously adding new code rather than refactoring or optimizing existing structures, which can result in redundant or incorrect unit tests. 1 The piece notes that there is currently no standardized process or reproducible control mechanism available to guarantee the quality of AI-generated output, making mandatory human review indispensable. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。