由前部长彼得·加勒特领导的社区调查委员会本周发布报告,建议澳大利亚立即取消核潜艇计划 1。2023年3月,加勒特曾撰文称斯科特·莫里森决定与前帝国强国合作建造核潜艇是“成本最高、风险最大的行动” 1。尽管6月洛伊研究所民调显示68%的澳大利亚人支持获取核动力潜艇,但调查仍建议解散相关安全监管机构 1。作者认为这可能导致盟友信任危机及国防能力真空 1。
调查委员会共有5名成员,其中4人此前曾批评AUKUS,包括前国防军长克里斯·巴里海军上将 1。报告提出了17项建议,其中16项针对政府和议会,1项针对更广泛的社会 1。报告声称皇家澳大利亚海军(RAN)“可能被迫主要根据美国的命令和利益行动”,但未确立主权丧失的具体机制 1。报告断言未来的美国弗吉尼亚级潜艇将“携带核武器”,尽管其部署尚不确定 1。
报告承认核潜艇可以“行驶更远、更快,在水下停留时间更长”,但将其描述为不适合防御海上通道的主要进攻平台 1。评论指出该调查存在预设立场和误解海事战略的问题,并批评其未提供可行的替代方案(Plan B) 1。报告要求澳大利亚“考虑并确定支柱一(Pillar I)的计划B”,但同时声明评论替代方案超出调查范围 1。
A community inquiry led by former minister Peter Garrett has recommended that Australia immediately cancel its nuclear-powered submarine program under the AUKUS agreement. 1 The panel, which comprises five members including four who have previously criticized AUKUS such as former Chief of Navy Chris Barrie, released a report this week containing 17 recommendations, with 16 directed at the government and parliament. 1 The findings call for the dissolution of the Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Regulator and the Federal Police’s AUKUS Command, despite public opinion polls from June showing that 68% of Australians support acquiring nuclear submarines. 1
The inquiry argues that the Royal Australian Navy could be forced to act primarily according to American commands and interests, although it did not establish the specific mechanisms for this potential loss of sovereignty. 1 Furthermore, the report asserts that future US Virginia-class submarines will carry nuclear weapons, even though their deployment remains uncertain. 1 While acknowledging that nuclear submarines can travel further, faster, and stay underwater longer than conventional vessels, the panel describes them as unsuitable main offensive platforms for defending sea lanes. 1
Critics point out significant flaws in the investigation's approach and outcomes. 1 The report demands that Australia consider and identify a "Plan B" for Pillar I of the deal but simultaneously states that commenting on alternatives is outside the scope of the inquiry. 1 In March 2023, Garrett described then-Prime Minister Scott Morrison’s decision to build nuclear submarines with former imperial powers in the Northern Hemisphere as the "most expensive and risky course of action." 1 This stance contrasts sharply with current public sentiment and raises concerns among observers about creating a defense capability vacuum and triggering a crisis of trust with allies. 1
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。