针对谷歌宣布将于2027年初起默认关闭K-12 Google Workspace教育账户中的AI工具一事,谷歌负责教育的副总裁Chris Phillips解释称,由于搜索与AI深度集成,无法在不影响搜索的情况下单独关闭AI功能。1 这一决定导致基础搜索功能也被连带停用。1 尽管谷歌随后调整政策,允许学校单独开启搜索,但核心争议在于技术捆绑迫使用户接受AI功能,因为即使开启搜索,也无法完全脱离AI概览等特性使用。1
Kagi公司营销负责人Kevin Elgan发表公开信,主张教育机构应拥有选择权而非被强制锁定,并推广其无广告、AI可选的搜索引擎作为替代方案。1 Elgan在信中引用观点指出“你根本无法速成理解”,并援引1998年斯坦福大学的一篇论文警告称,由广告资助的搜索引擎“本质上偏向广告商而远离消费者的需求”。1
Google has announced that artificial intelligence tools will be disabled by default in K-12 Google Workspace for Education accounts starting in early 2027 1. Chris Phillips, vice president for education at Google, explained the decision by stating, "Search and AI are deeply integrated," meaning one cannot be switched off without the other 1. Although schools may subsequently enable Search independently, they remain unable to use the service without associated AI features such as AI Overviews 1. This technical bundling has sparked criticism within the education sector regarding the potential erosion of students' independent thinking capabilities 1.
In response, Kevin Elgan, Head of Marketing at search engine company Kagi, published an open letter arguing that educational institutions should possess the autonomy to choose their tools rather than being forcibly locked into a specific ecosystem 1. Elgan contended that genuine learning cannot be rushed, stating, "You simply can't speed-run understanding" 1. To support his argument against forced integration, he referenced a 1998 Stanford paper which warned that advertising-funded search engines "will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of the consumers" 1. As an alternative solution, Elgan promoted Kagi’s search engine, highlighting its lack of advertisements and optional AI features 1.
评论
还没有评论,欢迎留下第一条。